Oh, the phoenix racer? That might actually be what I was looking at a while ago (when I cracked it open, it was ALL rusted). That's already a fast wound motor, nah? I think they called the slow-wind version the "phoenix brute".
Your saying it produces 2880watts at 72 volts is not quite right. It delivers that much only because you're running a 40 amp controller. Amps*Volts = watts. If you modify your controller to supply more current, you will have a higher power motor, even at 72volts.
I'm assuming by 51.8v, you're talking about 16s LiFePO4. Assuming you're running right now 24s LiFePO4, your max speed will be ~%30 more than what you're currently riding. That can be a problem, if you never intend on going that fast (it will likely be inefficient.) To be clear, increasing your voltage will increase the max speed which your bike wants to go at full throttle.
I'm pretty sure the crystalyte 40amp 72v controllers are capable of being modified to run higher amperage. I assume a shunt mod would be one easy method to jump up to 52amps, which would offer you quite a similar power increase.I think methods has a thread somewhere here detailing how to bring those up in power. be careful of hitting the thermal limits of your motor, however, if you're dealing with big hills. Don't want to burst your bubble that the cromotor hubzilla is a more powerful hub motor, because you are indeed talking about a rather powerful motor.