ES Rules - Have your say !

[Green Machine]

I am a chess player...

And one thing that makes the game funner and fairer is touch move...and once you take your hand off the piece the move is over. Without that rule players would have no discipline and the game would slip into chaos quickly. WHen i teach 5 year olds chess i teach them touch move...its good discipline and makes them think with there heads before they move...think with your head not with your fingers....perfect advice.

I see no reason why members should be allowed to edit their posts after they have posted. Especially after someone has commented on their post. In many cases it can make the poster after the fact look dumb unless he takes the time to quote the original poster first. Several times here on ES i have seen users respond to a post and the orginal poster just edit down his post which makes the responding poster looks silly...the responding poster then feels he should edit his post and it turns messy.

At-least editing posts after the fact should be discouraged...there should be a limit to number of posts one can edit in a week...or a time limit...lets say 10 minutes after posting. That would be my vote....10 minutes after making a post it become permanent...cannot be changed...a little less harsh than touch move.

These are easy setting in phpbb that could quickly be adjusted.

Also a lof of the fun of forums are the train wrecks that can sometimes happen when a poster types too hastily. Just as in chess...touch move forces users to be more careful on what they post. And if they arent careful bam....trainwreck...and like it or not trainwrecks are fun for fellow forum users to watch (I am guilty of a few of those trainwrecks) If you want less chaos on the forums...touch move may actually help that.

I recommend that ES goes to a touch move system..once you hit the post button...your turn is over...if you want to correct something you said....post again...and apologize.

By the way, before anyone jumps me, I will admit I am one of the most guilt for editing posts after the fact...i post too fast and type too fast thats for sure and go back later to clean up my errors because i can....so i am not being hypocritical...i am just saying that guys like me should be tamed down. I promise that i would not type so fast and post so fast if this rule were implemented.

Posts here should be forever....as originally posted. When posters realize there posts are forever they will be more careful and diligent when posting.

[Ypedal]

We tried that a few years ago, no good... we need to edit posts for the technical references and etc.... turned into an administration nightmare.

[Green Machine]

Makes perfect sense ypedal....nevermind....well how about user must type reason for edit..and be warned that edits are for technical corrections only? There is a "explain reason for edit" feature in phpbb...ES'ers are a great group and if they are just told that they cant edit content without good reason i think for the most part they would abide.

[Ypedal]

when a heated discussion comes along, users tend to " Quote " a post, that prevents the original member from from being changing his original post and hiding his remarks.

[Green Machine]

All those smiley faces are cheesy.

There aint many women posting on these forums whose idea was the smiley faces?

Someone should take those smiley faces off of here.

I think that anyone who over uses smiley faces should first be warned..second smiley face on one post they get a harsh heart to heart from a moderator....after 3 they are banned from the sphere forever. They are making us look dorky.

Wow this guys is brilliant...

Wait a minute....i can swear i wrote something like that earlier in this thread word by word....

Thats the first time i have been plagiarized on the sphere...thought it would never happen.

There should be some rule of stealing words from other members without quoting...

[Green Machine]

Wow that was like matrix...

Amberwolf just vaporized that guy...within seconds of me quoting him....

Nevermind i guess there was a rule about plagiarizing. That guy was just throttled. Serves him right.

[amberwolf]

Was a signature spammer. His IP was even found as a spammer on more than one of the anti-forumspam sites, as were variations on the username with that IP.

I hate spammers.

[1of3]

You can tell somebody that they are an idiot without being a rude idiot too. It just takes a bit more mental fortitude.

That is so cute.

Is this The Huntingtonpost..,?

[TylerDurden]

You can tell somebody that they are an idiot without being a rude idiot too. It just takes a bit more mental fortitude.

Some people look like idiots without any help.

Is this The Huntingtonpost..,?

[kevo]

>>At-least editing posts after the fact should be discouraged...there should be a limit to number of posts one can edit >>in a week...or a time limit...lets say 10 minutes after posting. That would be my vote....10 minutes after making a >>post it become permanent...cannot be changed...a little less harsh than touch move.

I appreciate edits, allows one to think/post freely. If restictions are placed on the edit time it tends to inhibit those that might post freely otherwise.

-Kevo

PS: ES Rules are excellent as they stand, any ammendments should be reviewed with grave concern for preserving the openness of the community as it now stands.

[Lessss]

Users real names should NOT be anonymous to the Admins.

[Joseph C.]

Very difficult to implement that. What's to stop people from adopting pseudonyms to use as their alter egos?

Personally, I prefer using real names on the forum and online but not everyone likes this.

[gtadmin]

Real names .... internet ..... And how would an admin verify a person's real name?

[daveyjones97]

the problem is that any forum will attract a generic cross section of society, all the liars, rapists cheats and thieves as well as the folk you want.
moderating looks like a mine field and tbh i dont see much wrong with es. yes you should jump on people who go looking for beef and the 3 strikes thing i like. locking useful posts i like.
one way i see of looking at the things folk have differing opinions on is: if theres doubt it should be changed, then theres no doubt it shouldnt be changed, if you follow.

[e-bike-is-fun]

Users real names should NOT be anonymous to the Admins.

Ok, all of Google, MSN, Yahoo and countless others should have only real names.?

Show us your real name here.

Put it in a reply to this.

This, your comment/thought of what should be what.

Come on.

Yea, only for such & such people.