by spinningmagnets » Sat Dec 11, 2010 8:11 pm
Cyclone has really missed the boat when it comes to updating their kit choices. I remember stories I've read where major bicycle manufacturers are in print as saying that mountain bikes are a fad and will remain a niche business. Would it have really been so much effort to have a younger staffer take pics of what the kids were doing on the trails, and make up a few frames to see how they sold at bike shows?
"Cyclone" has become a defining term for crank-drives, for goodness sake! How many times have you walked over to a Minolta or Ricoh in order to "Xerox" a page? EGO has a rare opportunity to DEFINE an interface. If EGO wanted advice designing their V2.0 drive, here's what Id recommend.
This is for an upscale market. There is no need to compromise by using an off-the-shelf motor. Define the goals and order a batch of housings, stator laminations, and have a custom winding. Up the volts to something between 36V and 48V, add hall sensors, make the motor form slightly narrower and slightly larger in diameter (Miles' motor is a good size and shape as a starter experiment)
The most frequent complaint is that theres a lot of chain noise because the motor-sprocket is very small (in order to avoid adding an additional-stage jack-shaft reduction). Matt has gone from a 3:1 to a 2:1 on his pulley-set to give the smaller pulley more tooth-engagement due to high power slippage. Not hard to do, IF...you add a jackshaft reduction. If a large company is affordably mass-making custom parts (making it harder for others to copy their results) The basic bracket set would hold their motor, a jackshaft, and two pulley/toothed-belt sets, so the primary/secondary stages were both fairly quiet belts.
The large pulley on the BB would be mounted to an ENO freewheel thats attached to a central aluminum spider, allowing the customer to change out the plastic BB-pulley to a different ratio. This would be similar to the Extron #219 sprocket series, where it is more expensive to set up a shaft with an Extron spider, but once thats done, sprocket high-tooth-count changes are only $20.
The defining interface I mentioned earlier would be between the motor/jackshaft holder, and a secondary adapter. The secondary adapter would mate the unchanging EGO bracket to every popular downhill frame. An aluminum machined/stamped bracket with appropriate custom tube-clamps, would be a separate item to order. Next years new frames would only need a new adapter.
Such an EGO component module could also be easily adapted to a left-side drive on the rear wheel...Right now I would buy one of Matts drives over an EGO or Cyclone any day...