Sunder
10 MW
Hi Everyone.
I suspect this question should have an easy answer to someone who understands it, and plenty of confusion from people who don't. It involves diodes, bad design, and magic smoke.
The story is that I'm using 3 x 20S BMS instead of 1 x 60S BMS. This is a LTO pack, so 162V max, 144V nominal. Don't judge me. It's hard enough to find any 60S BMS, let alone one that will support LTO.
The MOSFETs are rated for 100v only.
The charger is built from 3 x 48V isolated chargers in series, connected through the BMS.
So far, so good - In theory, I shouldn't need Schottky Diodes to protect the pack, because no BMS will ever see more than the charger voltage.
On the other hand... Regen. On a hard regen stop the system will probably see above the max voltage. Magic smoke time if that causes one of the BMSes to shut down, putting the full regen voltage through the remaining two.
So what are my options?
1. Schottky diodes across each pack? I know this is the recommendation, but no idea WHY, and therefore can't design it. Will a 200V, 70A Schottky be big enough? That's the biggest one I can find. I have no idea how much current I will be making in regen.
2. Set the over-voltage shutoff to be higher than recommended, knowing that LTOs are very tolerant to overcharge?
3. Route around the BMS for discharge, lose all the energy counters, and install my own?
Appreciate any feedback. Thanks.
I suspect this question should have an easy answer to someone who understands it, and plenty of confusion from people who don't. It involves diodes, bad design, and magic smoke.
The story is that I'm using 3 x 20S BMS instead of 1 x 60S BMS. This is a LTO pack, so 162V max, 144V nominal. Don't judge me. It's hard enough to find any 60S BMS, let alone one that will support LTO.
The MOSFETs are rated for 100v only.
The charger is built from 3 x 48V isolated chargers in series, connected through the BMS.
So far, so good - In theory, I shouldn't need Schottky Diodes to protect the pack, because no BMS will ever see more than the charger voltage.
On the other hand... Regen. On a hard regen stop the system will probably see above the max voltage. Magic smoke time if that causes one of the BMSes to shut down, putting the full regen voltage through the remaining two.
So what are my options?
1. Schottky diodes across each pack? I know this is the recommendation, but no idea WHY, and therefore can't design it. Will a 200V, 70A Schottky be big enough? That's the biggest one I can find. I have no idea how much current I will be making in regen.
2. Set the over-voltage shutoff to be higher than recommended, knowing that LTOs are very tolerant to overcharge?
3. Route around the BMS for discharge, lose all the energy counters, and install my own?
Appreciate any feedback. Thanks.