The fingers
10 TW
Prospero anos y felicidad. Happy New Year!
Forum Leadership
Submitted by Fechter on Tue, 01/30/2007 - 16:24.
OK, I can see this thing sort of stalled here, so I will try to get it moving again.
It seems the old Voltage Forum is toast, and even if Ken reappeared, there's a pretty large group of us that wouldn't go back due to the way he just let the thing die. Years of experience and thousands of posts went down the drain. Restoring backups may be more work than just starting from scratch.
The idea of a democratically organized forum seemed good in principle, but failed in execution. My feeling is most members don't really care how the admin runs as long as the board is there and they can post. In fact, the less direction you give them, the better.
Soooo.... How do we fix this semi-broken thing?
I'm open to suggestions, but this is what I would think:
We need a leader. A leader that most everybody likes. Not like our country's president. A leader that can make most of the decisions without involving too many people or requiring a huge debate. Representative government. It has to be somebody who both wants to do it and has time. Some skill would be useful also.
We need a backup leader for when the leader is on vacation, gets run over by a Hummer, or is kidnapped by Big Oil goons.
We need a technical team that can keep the site running and fix problems in the code.
In a democratic system, people run for office and you have an election.
Why not? It would take a somewhat long time frame to accomplish this since you would want a majority of the members to be aware of it and have a chance to vote before the deadline.
All this is just sort of scratching the surface, there's lots of details that need sorting out, like who's going to pay for the domain name and server space. Oh wait, that's what the treasurer does.
Step 1. determine the MINIMUM number of positons needed.
Step 2. open nominations for the positions and hope people apply.
Step 3. once you have enough "candidates", create a poll and have an election. I'd think you'd need to leave the polls open for at least a week. I don't know if cheating would be an issue. There's only so much you could do to stop it.
Once the new admin gets "sworn in", they run the show. If everyone votes for someone who has an enlightened attitude, we will all be in Nirvana, except for the occasional flame war and spam.
What do you other guys think?
A more long-winded version of this discussion is here: http://endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=172&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0
Another idea might be to might be to have a periodic poll for each of the admins (moderators, webmaster, whoever) that would simply be a vote of confidence. Sort of like a presidential approval rating. If, at any time, an "elected official" scores less than 50% approval, they should be replaced. Too bad it doesn't work like that in real politics.
A truely democratic government is perhaps impractical in cyberspace, but a representative government where leaders make decisions on their own on behalf of their constituants seems quite attainable.
There are many details to work out. I've been pretty busy with the "day job" lately, so I appologize for not moving faster on this.
What would we call the "leader" of the admin group anyway?
Supreme Commander?
President?
Chairman? (of the board - pun)
Most High Voltage One? you get the idea.
If members do not participate in this process, the decisions will be made without your input.
Exactly who is our moderation team at this point anyway?
Yes, but you've been such a good and kindly emperor, the silent partner with our best interests in mind, and to my knowledge - have never wielded Excalibur for personal gain. :wink:fechter said:As it turns out, I became "The Emperor" of ES.
I used to like reading the 'knights of the round table' stuff as a youngster and can easily see E-S in that light; EVangelic members united by a common value:Kingfish said:Yes, but you've been such a good and kindly emperor, the silent partner with our best interests in mind, and to my knowledge - have never wielded Excalibur for personal gain. :wink:fechter said:As it turns out, I became "The Emperor" of ES.
With that, I would gladly follow your lead good Sir.
Well done indeed. KF
fechter said:8 years now, and almost a million posts.
Special thanks to Justin and the moderator crew here that keeps ES alive.
The electric revolution is slowly taking off and we're really a bunch of pioneers here making it happen.