40T cycle test

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
I will keep adding the test results every 50 cycles to this original post

40T
VH88Fmx.jpg


capacity test

gnMQLYW.png


cycle #1 results and settings

sjzNwy7.jpg


3dF3u0L.png


discharge #50

pSIMTKr.png


2WXv41k.jpg


discharge 100

YMhlzSS.png


lvCyILu.jpg


discharge 149

fjluOy5.png


YuGAeZS.jpg


discharge 200

YdMaHg9.png


rjORxSJ.jpg


discharge 300

IsK6hZ2.png


pvRIGbd.jpg


discharge 351

1CxhsuB.png


vZZBod5.jpg


discharge 400

JbFQ3WL.png


9akHyn4.jpg
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
saved, Capacity at different lifecycle counts

original test before cycling

LmRCMNl.png


after 126 cycles

KSkWRmc.png


after 250 cycles

U7hR3ba.png


after 375 cycles

m5QGEtz.png


463 cycles 3703mah

xtOI79D.png


heres 126 but a wider view to get a better look at where the capacity loss is occurring

XvXs3ze.png


wider 250

XfmP7B8.png


wider 375

fCrvrF7.png
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
ive made changes to the charge settings to see if I can slow the degradation of the cell in, 1-7 of the new settings/ d-cc 2.50a to 3.2v

the change in fast charge settings seems to be working, when I first started cycling I was losing about 2.85mah/cycle, I continued to make slight changes and got to about losing 1.85mah/cycle. I didn't think the cell would last 300 cycles but with the new changes im losing 1 mah or less/cycle. I might make 750 cycles with 80% capacity now.

heres cycle 1 charge numbers 3156 mah , discharge #2 3191 mah

B8NG8tK.jpg



heres cycle 49 charge numbers 3153mah, discharge #50 3189 mah

2WXv41k.jpg


heres cycle 54 charge numbers 3149mah, discharge #55 3185 mah

RWhXXdd.jpg


#100 discharge capacity was 3176 mah

made more changes this is discharge #149, 3184 mah, yes it increased

YuGAeZS.jpg


#200 charge 3091mah, discharge 3140mah

rjORxSJ.jpg


#300 charge 3017mah, discharge 3055mah

pvRIGbd.jpg


#351 charge 2994mah, discharge 3039mah

vZZBod5.jpg


#400 charge 2971mah, discharge 3016mah

9akHyn4.jpg
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
at cycle 95 I changed the discharge settings to make the battery run warmer, the weather cooled off and the room temperature was 69f, battery temp dropped to 71f for its low and the capacity was suffering so I increased amps, now battery temperatures remain steady between 90f and 75f and capacity is recovering.
it also seems if I can keep the start of charge temperature around 80f/81f I can maintain capacity loss to a minimum but at 82f/83f I start losing.

heres the battery temps at different stages

start of charge 80f
when 2amp charge switches to 3.75amps is 78f
when 3.75ap charge switches to cut-off amps 83f
end of charge 75f and start of discharge 75f
10amp to 7.5amp switch 85f
7.5amp to 5amp switch 90f
5amp to 1.5amp switch 88f
end of discharge 82f

the battery is performing almost too good. im at 3173 mah after 104 discharges. it started at 3191mah. that's only an 18mah loss after 104 cycles or 0.17mah/cycle. im going to do the 0.8amp discharge from 4.2v to 2.5v tomorrow to compare with the original test I performed before cycling to see the capacity and compare.
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
I think capacity loss is from charging initially at 5amp

cjsfUBH.png


heres a capacity test of a different 40T that I was playing with, at 7amp discharge from 4.2v to 3.0 volts the battery temperature would peak at 107f. I thought it was heat that was killing the capacity down around 3.4v to 3.2v but now I think it was the 5amp charge

I6tMzVc.png
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
i made some changes, I want keep atleast 50% of the cells discharge capacity being used at or above 7.5 amps. it raised peak battery temperature to 95f. then I gave the battery a 5 minute rest between charge/discharge/charge heres the new graph and numbers

7Fpd9G8.png


2gd56m8.jpg


im testing the battery inside a closed cardboard box with a towel ontop to keep battery temperatures up. I don't open it up.
the other morning I noticed the discharge mah numbers were getting higher??? so I checked the battery temperature on my dmm and all the temperatures had increased by 5f.
I opened the box and the battery had slid up against the side of the cardboard box, just touching the cardboard increased battery temperature to 95f peak and improved the capacity available numbers.
I guess a ghost had moved my box

against cardboard
LUyhBom.jpg


I moved it back and temperatures dropped 5f and the capacity dropped again
yEGsWAS.jpg


ill do another 4.2v to 2.5v capacity test at cycle 250

I noticed on the charts once I switched the rest time in between charge and discharge from 1 minute to 5 minutes, the at rest voltage dropped from 4.2v to 4.194v at 70 seconds then at 90 seconds it dropped to 4.191v and at 4m50s to 4.190 and discharge starts again at 5 minute mark.
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.

999zip999

100 TW
Joined
Jan 10, 2010
Messages
11,453
Location
Dana Point So. Cal
90amps powervelocity 18 get with a muxus 3,000 4t v3 or it fits my Kona kukapu triangle. So thinking of cyclone 3,000 or a lr long block frist gen so 7 yrs old or what motor you suggest ? Buying now as my muxus 150mm wouldn't fit frame. So the battery sould be extra large for it's needs plus copper series buss bars wrapped in nickle.
Ok 90amp BMS continuous and 180 amp peak.
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
im just looking at running a phaserunner at 60 amps with 4p of 40T and a 15amp charger for fast 1 hour charging.
I was looking at the mxus v3 4t to go with it but the hs3540 that im running seems about the same on grins simulator only lighter. haven't decided which one yet. I like the silence of a DD

I bought a molicel p42a 21700 to test when im done this at same settings.
 

999zip999

100 TW
Joined
Jan 10, 2010
Messages
11,453
Location
Dana Point So. Cal
Cycltye hubs I had a 3525 junk and a 3525 hanging in the rafters. It runs but it goes thump thump thump thump thump. You can come by a pick it up no shipping. Small trade.
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
I made more changes to increase battery temperature, it was also rainy today so I turned on the furnace to warm up the house.

that increased the battery temperatures and the battery seemed to like it. heres the temperatures.
start of discharge 80f/26c, 10/7switch 94f/34c, 7.5/5 switch 100f/38c, 5/1.5 switch 97f/36c, end of discharge 89f/32c, start of charge 86f/30c, 2/3.75 switch 82f/28c, 3.75/cut off amp 90f/32c, end of charge 80f

after 100 cycles 3176 mah
after 149 cycles 3184mah

im trying to get the battery to run as close to 10 amps as I can without getting it too hot, im just going to let it cycle for awhile at these settings, its been putting out a steady number.
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
the 200th cycle numbers are posted, I need to adjust the 1-d-cc and 2-d-cc voltages lower about 0.02v to raise peak temperatures to 100f to increase capacity again. peak temperature had dropped to 97f.
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
house was warm last night and checked the battery, temp was at 104f peak and the capacity had dropped. I was running the cycle settings so the battery temp would peak at 100f and after a few cycles the capacity would level out with steady numbers. im going to change peak temperatures to 99f on cycle #231.
edit to add pictures.
never saw these glitches in the discharge chart before, but this is #231 with new settings for 99f

XAVXI0d.png


fBzAwit.png
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
im doing the 4.2v-2.5v at 0.8 discharge test for 250 cycles thought id share the capacity at different voltages. battery temp is 73f
*edit* im going to add some numbers from cycle #375 for comparison

3.9v, 1012mah cycle #375
QHVU6bl.png


3.8v, 1460mah
zJdp2cf.png



3.6v, 2324mah
MKkWuF9.png


#375-3.6v, 2299mah
B0IcuVG.png


3.5v, 2712mah
YKkRS0I.png


3.4v, 3043mah
1zgHC5e.png


3.3v, 3144mah
8gp6FOe.png


#375-3.3v, 3086mah
m0hDqLo.png


3.2v, 3220mah
hMdmfuB.png


#375-3.2v, 3166mah
AnDbV09.png
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
finished cycle #290 discharge 3062mah, charge 3023mah

discharge #2 was 3191mah, that's 95% after 290 cycles. you really cant go with the cycle numbers because its too easy to manipulate the capacity numbers with temperature and I have been, at cycle #149 I was using closer to the temperatures im using now and the capacity was 3184mah.

the 4.2vto2.5v capacity test will have to be the reference

im running the battery a little hotter where it peaks at 101/102f and only lose about 0.3mah/cycle right now

n7S21dt.jpg


5DlSmvz.jpg


DIWQ2o6.png
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
the cycle time has been increasing and its the charge cycle that is taking longer. I might have to drop the charge amps so I can make the charge faster, might try 3.25amps

IsK6hZ2.png


I changed to 3.7a charge no real change except the curve

u4ZPVcU.png


tried 3.65

Cq4AIRM.png


3.85 is a little faster

eRoGnBe.png


4.0, a little slower

2g1Otg6.png


4.25a is faster,

qVnHv3q.png


the charging mah was 5mah higher than the previous 5 cycles but the problem was the battery temperature at end of charge, it was 77f/78f and took 7 minutes for temp to reach 76f/75f. I need the battery cycle test to start at 75f/76f or else peak discharge temps get too high

3.82amps

byl2Wk3.png
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
quite a bit more volt sag

#127
3lbUg8X.png


#323
90RYaUK.png


I saw fully charged voltage had dropped to 3.184v, I put charge amps back to 3.75a from 3.82a
#330
4JadBTY.png


when cycling, normally start of discharge voltage is 4.191v, ive increased the 10amp discharge time, im still within peak temperatures, to speed up cycle time and will play with lower charge amps to see if I can increase the 4.191v at Start of discharge.

D3KOYdb.png


tried 3.5a and 3.0a with no observable change to voltage or mah, tried 2.5amp charge and again, no change so put charge amps back to 3.75amps

RRcZEBi.png
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
#400 discharge was 3016mah, #100 discharge was when i had figured out the charge/discharge settings and that was 3176mah.

the battery lost 160mah over the last 300 cycles.

going to put this test on hold after discharge #450 to test another cell
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
the cell was getting damaged by the 3.6amp charge and was losing about 2mah per cycle over the first 100 cycles until i switched to starting charge at 2amps and finishing with 3.75a-0.10c/o, you could see the damage at the 4.2-2.5 capacity chart at cycle 125 and then the damage stopped.

makes me think if you kept the charge to 2amps this cell would do 1000cycles. i had to change the 2a/3.75a switch to 3.62v because the cell still suffers loss where it was switching at 3.6v, that was 150/200? cycles ago and it needs to be moved again to 3.64v.

the other thing is temperature, max temp is about 102f and if you keep battery temp between 102f and 95f it gives its best consistent capacity.

im going to be testing a molicel p42a and mnke 26650 20amp 5000mah at the same settings.
 

goatman

10 MW
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
3,173
Location
Surrey, B.C.
p42a and mnke liked longer wait times than the 40T, instead of 5minutes and 2minutes they like 30min and 5min so im trying these settings to compare mah loss per cycle

JvMLjLd.jpg


battery has been sitting on the shelf for 30 days, voltage dropped by 0.07 volts, its last discharge was 3016mah. charged to 4.2v to start test

cycle #422 battery discharge starting voltage was 4.2v, #423 was 4.191v

#422 d-3040mah, c-2965mah
#423 d-3016mah, c-2975mah
#424 d-3021mah, c-2979mah
#425 d-3022mah, c-2981mah
#426 d-3024mah, c-2982mah
#427 d-3024mah, c-2982mah
#428 d-3023mah, c-2982mah
#429 d-3024mah, c-2983mah
#430 d-3021mah, c-2979mah- the box the battery is in was open and peak temp dropped. closed lid again
#431 d-3020mah, c-2979mah
#432 d-3021mah, c-2980mah
#433 d-3021mah, c-2980mah- aug7, 7pm done for now.
 
Top