Kemosabe70 said:
I can order a Mac motor from em3ev tonight, I don’t know which winding to get to match my needs/ battery.
If your needs are for torque (quicker startups from a stop, etc) rather than speed, then the slowest wind they have available will be better, as long as that will still get you the top speed you want. Both the 10t and 12t will easily go over 20MPH in 700c wheel size with a 52v battery, so speed shouldn't be a problem.
This comparison between the 10t and 12t in a 700c wheel, 52v battery, 20A controller (so about 1000w), shows you get about 24MPH with the 12t, and about 27mph with the 10t, with the 12t having more torque.
https://www.ebikes.ca/tools/simulator.html?motor=MMAC12T&batt=B5213_GA&hp=0&axis=mph&motor_b=MMAC10T&batt_b=B5213_GA&hp_b=0&bopen=true&wheel=700c&wheel_b=700c
This shows that at 20MPH, the 12t is slightly more efficient (barely) than the 10T, so you might get slightly better range out of it. Probably moreso the more often you have to startup from a stop, and less difference the longer your straight steady runs are.
https://www.ebikes.ca/tools/simulator.html?motor=MMAC12T&batt=B5213_GA&hp=0&axis=mph&motor_b=MMAC10T&batt_b=B5213_GA&hp_b=0&bopen=true&wheel=700c&wheel_b=700c&mass=150&mass_b=150&autothrot=true&autothrot_b=true&throt_b=67.6&throt=78.4
This shows that at a startup from a stop, acceleration is higher with the 12t than the 10t. If you move the vertical dotted lines to new positions at various speeds, you can see the change in accelertation as you get faster. (acceleration is the top right number in the bottom boxes of numbers).
https://www.ebikes.ca/tools/simulator.html?motor=MMAC12T&batt=B5213_GA&hp=0&axis=mph&motor_b=MMAC10T&batt_b=B5213_GA&hp_b=0&bopen=true&wheel=700c&wheel_b=700c&mass=150&mass_b=150&autothrot=false&autothrot_b=false&throt_b=100&throt=100
They only offer a cycle analyst v2 (not sure if v3 is better and why and if it is I’d get it) and no regular display..do I need a display too?
The v2 is the basic version, which will monitor power usage, battery level, etc., and can provide throttle override function to do speed / power /current limiting, but doesn't do the advanced stuff v3 does, like PAS cadence or torque sensors (to control the motor without throttle), direct throttle modulation for the various limiting functions, temperature monitoring, etc. You can read about the differences on the ebikes.ca info pages for each one, if you like, or ask specific questions here.
If you don't need any of the v3-specific features, the v2 works just fine, if you do want a power usage monitor (not necessary, but can be useful for troubleshooting; there are much cheaper wattmeters if that is all you want it for, but they have none of the other features the CA does).
They’re also sold out of throttles so maybe I can just grab everything from grin?
Grin has the GMAC kits, but those have no internal freewheel/clutch like the MAC does, so if it is not powered on and a little power applied (even when not using the motor to move with), it will have a fair bit of drag trying to pedal it, especially with a singlespeed bike. As long as you use the Cycle analyst v3 to setup the throttle to always have a little bit of throttle going to the motor to keep it "free", then that's not an issue...except if you ever run out of battery, or if something fails in the system.
The advantage is the GMAC doesn't have the vulnerability of the clutch to break, so it could be a bit more reliable than the regular MAC.
The GMAC has a temperature sensor that the CAv3 can monitor and rollback power if it gets too hot, too, though that's unlikely in your usage scenario.
The GMAC can do regen braking, whcih the MAC can't because of it's freewheeling clutch. But you don't need that. (you could use it to get a bit of extra range, a few percent at most, but I don't think you need that either).
Regarding throttles, you can get one of those from anywhere. If the kit you order has Higo connectors, then even Amazon has Higo-connectorized throttles of various types (and has other connector types as well if you need them). I recommend getting one that has at least 1/2-rotation
I am also unsure of which controller to get, be it an Infineon controller from em3ev (and then if so idk which I’d get 6fet, 9fet, 12fet) or something else from somewhere else? I plan on mounting the controller underneath my rear rack for a clean look.
Typically a 12FET can have a 20-30A current limit, which would be ok for the MAC if you're not running it at full power all the time (whcih you won't, if you're not climbing hills all the time or hauling big heavy unaerodynamic loads, etc.). My guess is you'll use around 300-500w or so most of the time for your usage scenario, which at 52v is only about 10A or less, so even a little 6FET would work. More power means quicker acceleration. The simulator can be used to compare that, too.
For instance, this uses the 12t, witha 10A vs a 20A controller, and shows about doulbe the accleration for the 20A vs the 10A.
https://www.ebikes.ca/tools/simulator.html?motor=MMAC12T&batt=B5213_GA&hp=0&axis=mph&motor_b=MMAC12T&batt_b=B5213_GA&hp_b=0&bopen=true&wheel=700c&wheel_b=700c&mass=150&mass_b=150&autothrot=false&autothrot_b=false&throt_b=100&throt=100&cont=cust_10_20_0.03_V
Also, is the GMAC that much better?? It’s SO much more expensive.
Most of the stuff from Grin is more expensive than elsewhere, because you're also paying for potentially better support if you have the need, and R&D to make new and better ebike stuff. Sometiems you're also paying for better build quality; I don't have experience with the GMAC so couldn't say on that one--you'd have to look around the forum to see what those with one say about them.
I've been both impressed and disappointed by various Grin stuff. The Grinfineon controllers disappointed me, though they aren't bad, just not as good as I expected. The Satiator charger impressed me for the last five years. The Cycle Analyst impresses me, in all the various versions I have...though it doesn't do things exactly the way I want them, it works well enough for most purposes, and allows one to do things not possible with some systems without it.
If I were building a bike to do what you want to do, I'd do it as I answer below:
Which winding for the Mac?
I'd use the 12t.
Which controller/display?
If not using the battery to it's max capacity very often, no display is needed. If using it's capacity a fair bit, a wattmeter of some type would be a useful item; the CAv2 works but even something like the Turnigy Watt Meter or any of the cheap wattmeters works, and I'd probably just use that.
Do I even need a display If I get the CA?
No...if it's generic controller with no settings or programmability. But if it's a controller that does have internal settings and has a display option to access them, you require the display specific to that controller to do that.
For instance, if you get like a KT type controller, etc., that supports PAS, or assist levels, you need the display to be able to change to anything other than the default level, or to setup what those levels do, etc.
If you get something like the basic Grinfineons, or other types like that, they dont' have a display option, or assist levels, etc. They just are what they are, which makes for a simple system, but less options. Most likely, you'd be fine with just the basic stuff like that.
Is the GMAC worth it over the Mac?
Only if you need the potential extra power you might be able to get out of it, since you don't need it for regen braking. I myself would just use the regular MAC for your needs.