ELF SOLO "Repower"

ConquistaThor

10 µW
Joined
Jan 1, 2022
Messages
5
I am looking at purchasing a 2008 Elf Solo. The unit was flood damaged and all of the batteries, controllers, and throttles have been removed. The motor has been taken out of the "loop" but I have the damaged motor and brackets. I am wanting to try to establish a reasonable budget get this unit back into usable condition. I want this Elf as a usable mode of transportation, more so than getting into a time and money consuming additional hobby so am not looking at this from the "enthusiast side".

My understanding is that the units shipped with a TDCM motor mid drive motor.

I assume once I find a motor that physically fits and works, sorting out controllers, batteries, and BMS, and other electrics will revolve around the motor.

Would something like BAFANG BBSHD at the 1KW power rating be basically what I am looking for to get a motor installed with minimal fabrication and design.

Thanks for all your help.

Thor
 
1 325,19 zł | QSMOTOR138-B 70H 3000W BLDC PMSM Mid-drive Motor For Electric Motorcycle
https://a.aliexpress.com/_uJo0Qv

This is what you need. Says 3 kw but you can push 10kw if ever need to no problem. Just the installation will need a bit of fabrication of brackets and supports


Sent from my POCO F2 Pro using Tapatalk

 
ConquistaThor said:
I am looking at purchasing a 2008 Elf Solo.
This? (in whatever the 2008 version looked like)
https://organictransit.com/product/elf-solo/
(note that the more info and details you provide, the better we can help ;) )

If it's a delta version (one front wheel) and has the shell around the cranks, then you'd need to modify or remove the shell to fit a BB mounted middrive.

If it's a tadpole version (two front wheels) then there is probably room around the BB to fit middrives, as long as the frame shape is correct for them. Might require removing some floorboard around the cranks, depends on how that specific Solo is built.

If it's the hubmotor-middrive version, then it's really easy to do as long as you have all the old motor mounting hardware.

The motor has been taken out of the "loop" but I have the damaged motor and brackets.
Before replacing it, I would test it (first by just spinning it on it's axle by hand, if it spins freely it is likley not damaged inside) or check the inside of the motor to see if it was water damaged. If it is similar build quality to the TDCM Stromer hubmotor I have, it is possible it was well-enough sealed to prevent water intrusion. If you're not sure how to open it, you can post complete pics here by attaching them to your posts and we can see if it is possible from those. Before opening it, though, you can post the pics of the cabling and connectors so we can see if it has regular phase/hall wiring or if it has the internal controller--if there's no internal controller you can test it with just about any standard brushless controller.

If yours is like this:
https://anyonecanbike.com/repairs/elf-first-aid/what-does-that-tdcm-motor-look-like-inside/
then it is a hubmotor mounted as a middrive, and you can then use any similar hubmotor as a middrive. But you probably don't have to change the motor, because it's probably not water damaged inside. As long as it doesn't have a controller inside it (the Stromer version I have did, but I removed it and now run it on my trike with an external), you can just hook up a controller that has the power level and features you need, and use the motor and brackets you already have.


I am wanting to try to establish a reasonable budget get this unit back into usable condition. I want this Elf as a usable mode of transportation, more so than getting into a time and money consuming additional hobby so am not looking at this from the "enthusiast side".
My understanding is that the units shipped with a TDCM motor mid drive motor.
If it was a middrive previously, then another middrive would likely be the best option (so you retain the ability to shift gears for the motor system). There are a few ways of making and mounting a middrive, so knowing how yours was done before will help us help you find the best matching option.

If you can post pics of the drive mounting area of the actual Solo you're going to get, and the original drive unit and mounting brackets, it will help us help you figure out if any currently-available commercial middrive units will fit it without modification of the drive or the Solo.



Most of the middrives that fit on the BB area are designed for a fairly narrow range of frame designs, and may closely fit the frame/BB such that any frame that doesnt' match the more typical shapes and sizes may not fit the drive without (potentially serious) modification of one or both.

Any regular old hubmotor can be used as a middrive as well, Stokemonkey-style (or a few other ways), but that's a fair bit of fabrication to do. This is how at least some ELFs were made, like the one I linked above--if yours is this way, you don't need any fabrication, and you just put the TDCM motor in there and new controller/etc., or you replace it with a new hubmotor of similar size.


BTW, that same site has other repair info you may need
https://anyonecanbike.com/repairs/elf-first-aid/
if yours is a similar enough model.
 
I have attached some images of the drive motor it had, as well as the unit. It has the two wheels in the front and single rear drive motor. The prior owner as "messed with it", so I am getting something in parts pieces and trying to sort out how it was, so I can sort out how to fix it. I can turn a wrench and am an EE, but when my pedal bike needs sorting out I take it to the bike shop, so all this is new to me, so forgive me for sounding dumb.

This unit has nuvinci n360 hub mounted CVT. All of the controllers, throttles, etc have been removed from the unit, the only thing remaining is a heavily corroded motor laying on the floor of the unit.

The owner said he replaced the chain and moved the rear wheel forward - that the motor went inline with the chain to the rear wheel. Looking online I am seeing multiple chain setups so not sure if this true or not.

A complete hub motor replacement would be awesome if it will work for this application as it makes everything much simplier - not sure how that works with the hub mounted transmission.

Replacing the two front wheels with hub mounted motors would create steering problems and lots of torque steer correct - he suggested that as an option to get up and moving easily.

Thanks for all your guys patience and help.

Thanks!
Thor
 

Attachments

  • motor-sproket.jpg
    motor-sproket.jpg
    574.4 KB · Views: 319
  • brokemotor.jpg
    brokemotor.jpg
    502.7 KB · Views: 319
  • Unit.jpg
    Unit.jpg
    783.8 KB · Views: 319
ConquistaThor said:
This unit has nuvinci n360 hub mounted CVT. All of the controllers, throttles, etc have been removed from the unit, the only thing remaining is a heavily corroded motor laying on the floor of the unit.
The outside of the motor and the sprocket do look pretty bad, but if you can still spin the axle in the housing without any grating/grinding, then it is probably still good inside and will probably still work. It is outwardly identical to the motor I have, which is well built and sealed up pretty good (at least, before I messed with it to take the dead internal controller out). ;)

Since the connector is cut off on the motor cable, then I can't tell whether it is the type with internal controller. If you can strip back a little of the outer jacket and expose the individual wires in it, and spread them out a bit for a good clear closeup pic, it might show if they are the ones for the internal controller type (like stromer uses) or separate phase and hall wires for a standard external controller.

If you don't want to mess with it, you can pick any typical rear hubmotor with 135mm axle shoulder width (most of them are like this), and replace the TDCM motor with it. http://ebikes.ca has complete kits you can get, all ready to install; just ask them for a motor that is not in the wheel when you buy since you don't need the rim or spokes and they carry bare motors the same as the ones in the kit wheels. If you tell them what you are replacing and doing with it they can even help you make sure you get the right "winding" and other stuff to work similarly to the original ELf system.

There are also many cheap ebay/etc kits but they will come in a wheel, you'd just unlace the wheel (you could sell the rim and spokes and tire to recoup some small cost). For these you must research what they have and how well they'll work for your purpose as the sellers don't generally know anything at all about what they sell (though they are often happy to invent stuff to tell you about it!).

Getting the TDCM out without damaging the mounts may require cutting the axle nuts off carefully (gridning or filing them away), as they look solidly rusted together.

YOu'll progbably have to decorrode the idler (next to the axle mount) and replace whatever bearings it has. Same with all other bearings in the trike. Don't know about the wheels themselves (rims, spokes); if they're corroded you may have to replace the wheels.

The owner said he replaced the chain and moved the rear wheel forward - that the motor went inline with the chain to the rear wheel. Looking online I am seeing multiple chain setups so not sure if this true or not.

A complete hub motor replacement would be awesome if it will work for this application as it makes everything much simplier - not sure how that works with the hub mounted transmission.

That unit looks essentially like what is in the link I provided.

There are a few ways to run the chainline for a setup like this, so I would first refer to the link, and then you might also see if you can reach Organic Transit to see if they have "service manuals" for the model you have (the serial number on it will tell them what it is), at least something sufficient to mechanically set it up like it originally was built.

If you can't get that, and the link stuff doesn't match or have enough info to help, then we can figure out the simplest way to do it with the parts you already have plus minimal added stuff.

THe system is probably designed to run the chain from the cranks back to the Nuvinci's freewheel cluster, to input the pedal power into that just like it would if it were in a wheel. Then the NV probably has a drive sprocket bolted to it's shell, either on the flange the drive (chain) side, or on the disc brake mounts on the left side. Then that probably has a chain back to a sprocket bolted to the motor's disc brake side. There is then probably a sprocket mounted to the motor's right side that uses another chain back to the actual wheel's input sprocket.

There are other variations, including the way Rassy did it here:
https://endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=28&t=47043&p=689633&hilit=motor+chain#p711850
https://endless-sphere.com/forums/download/file.php?id=103994
https://endless-sphere.com/forums/download/file.php?id=101705
that uses a single chain to pass the pedal power thru the chain over/under the motor and back to the IGH and then to the wheel. He has another build (yellow trike?) that does something similar but I think it was even simpler.
 
Thank for you the in-depth reply. I'll pick the unit up hopefully this weekend and can start figuring out what I have and how to get it running. I'll follow up as I work through your list of items and certainly let the group know how the project turns out.

Thanks and Happy New Year!
Thor
 
If you take good clear pics of each part of the trike from different angles (labelling what they are) then we may be able to help you find alternate replacements for things taht aren't repairable or still available from Organic Transit, etc., and also suggest repair methods for parts that need that and can be.

It'll also be good documentation for anyone else that has or gets an ELF and needs to modify or repair it. :) Or that wants to build a similar design on their own.
 
Yes I am sure this thread will turn into a build thread - I want to personally thank everyone that has been kind enough to reply so far.

The electronics, and system controls don't scare me its the basic "high end" bicycle stuff where I am lacking.

That said this should be a pretty fun project, and hopefully a great tool for what I want to use it for! Looking forward to picking it up and getting an honest assessment of where I am at and how to get it back on the road!
 
So I got a chance to take a few motor photos of the unit today and re-read all of the helpful tips above.

I did find a a spare sprocket which I think did fit on the disk break side of the rear axle to provide input power from the original motor. That motor was salt water submerged and is seized solid. All other controls and electrics are missing from the unit.

I am pretty certain I want to tackle this with a hub motor conversion, and change the front drive pedal sprocket to much smaller one to provide some ability to pedal the unit for emergency use or repositioning.

I have been looking at the ebikes.ca site which had a ton of helpful information. If I cannot find anything domestic I'll contact them, as they have one of the best sites out there.

Why would I want to change the rim and spokes if I can find one ready to go - saw a video on how to do it, but, what is forcing me to swap the rims around?


Thanks!
Thor
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1201.jpg
    IMG_1201.jpg
    207.5 KB · Views: 263
  • IMG_1207.jpg
    IMG_1207.jpg
    134.3 KB · Views: 263
  • IMG_1208.jpg
    IMG_1208.jpg
    179.5 KB · Views: 263
ConquistaThor said:
That motor was salt water submerged and is seized solid.
Yeah, then you'll have to replace it. :(





I am pretty certain I want to tackle this with a hub motor conversion, and change the front drive pedal sprocket to much smaller one to provide some ability to pedal the unit for emergency use or repositioning.
Presumably the hubmotor wil replace the Nuvinci IGH that is in the rear wheel?

If the motor will be the only thing running it most of the time, and you won't ever need to pedal at more than one very low speed, you can use a very large rear sprocket and a very small front sprocket, and no shiftable gearing between them, to get high torque but low speed.

I do something like this on my SB Cruiser trike. Though I do have a 3speed IGH in the chainline in the frame between pedals and wheel, it stays in the lowest gear 99% of the time. For me, pedalling is used to control the motor system, and the motor provides all the actual power, because my body is pretty worn out in all the wrong places, and I have to save what ability I do have for the other things I have to do that I can't replace with motors. ;)

If you think you'll need more than one gear, I'd go ahead and put an IGH in the chainline like it probably originally had (if it is like the site I linked), so you don't have to deal with derailers/etc. A simple 3-speed IGH would likely do for most things, with a low gear, a 1:1 gear, and a high gear. Different ratios are available, or you can use an IGH with more gears (typically less gears mean they're wider inside and thus a little stronger and wear out less quickly), or even a NuVinci for continously variable gearing. If you don't have the mounting brackets for that, you can use the ones for the motor instead.
https://www.sheldonbrown.com/internal-gears.html
http://john-s-allen.com/gears/hubratios.htm

I did find a a spare sprocket which I think did fit on the disk break side of the rear axle to provide input power from the original motor.

FWIW, I don't see a disc caliper mount or caliper on that rear wheel area. Is there one that is just not visible? (if there isn't one, then no need to even have the disc mounted; leaves space for the sprocket if you do want to do it as below:)

If you are doing a hubmotor in the wheel conversion, and are using an IGH inline with the pedal chainline, then you can use that same sprocket on the hubmotor's disk brake mount to accept the pedal chain output from the IGH, pretty much just like the original design probably was. I would put the IGH as close to the rear wheel as possible, so that the always-spinning chain you'll have from it to the wheel is as short as possible.

If you don't have an IGH or some other freewheeling device between that sprocket and the pedals (assuming the pedal chainrings are used on the left side to line up with it in this use case), then the entire chainline and pedals will be forced to spin all the time the ELF is in motion, either forwards or backwards.

Alternately you can run a regular freewheeling sprocket on the right side of the hubmotor in the wheel, and keep a single chain from the pedals to the rear, and the chain and pedals will only move when you are pedalling. If you install a derailer on the rear as well as a multisprocket cluster on the wheel, then you can shift gears too.

Keep in mind that the longer the chain is, the more important it is to keep proper tension on it, or else it can bounce on bumps/holes while pedalling so that the chain comes off the top of the pedal chainring and jams up (doesn't usually happen if the chain isn't being pulled, so if you stop pedalling before each bump or hole, and only resume after the chain isn't bouncing, that works too).

Ghost rings (unattached chainrings stuck between the top and bottom runs of chain along the length of a long chainline) can help keep this from happening, if they are large enough to push the runs apart and keep them tensioned, but if a bump does separate the runs because of insufficient tension, the ghost rings will fall out. ;)



I have been looking at the ebikes.ca site which had a ton of helpful information. If I cannot find anything domestic I'll contact them, as they have one of the best sites out there.

Yes, Grin Tech (ebikes.ca) is one of the most complete places to get information and ebike stuff; they are also inventors and developers of various things (they don't just buy various chinese/etc things and have their stickers put on them like most places do; they do sell some stuff like that, but the products that carry their name are actually theirs). They're not perfect, and sometimes they are so busy it is hard to get hold of them, but I haven't found any other place that is consistently any better at that part. :( They actually keep this forum alive, too, having rescued it some years back from it's originator who was selling it off.

They also have something else useful for determining what system might work best for a particular bike and situation: http://ebikes.ca/tools/simulator.html




Why would I want to change the rim and spokes if I can find one ready to go - saw a video on how to do it, but, what is forcing me to swap the rims around?

If you are going for a hubmotor in the wheel rather than redoing the original hubmotor as a middrive, then there is no reason to remove the rim and spokes from the motor; you just order the hubmotor with the correct diameter rim for your frame (same as the original that you are replacing, presumably the rear), and the correct width rim for the tires you wish to use on it (taht will still fit within the frame).

Some advantages of a hubmotor in the wheel system:
--simple; less things in the chainline to align and tension during setup
--only the pedal drive uses the chain, less wear on the chaindrive system
Some disadvantages:
--weaker wheel (shorter spokes, different angles, etc)
--heavier wheel and more hardware to attach it (harder to fix flats, etc)
--dropouts not typically designed to deal with hubmotor axle torque, so special hardware has to be installed and secured to do that
--motor has to directly do all the work to the wheel, no gearing changes are possible for it (just for pedals); motor (and controller/battery) may need to be more powerful to do the same work under some conditions

The only reason to remove the rim and spokes from the hubmotor is if you are going to use the drive the same way it was originally built, by placing the hubmotor in the frame and running the pedal chain thru / past it to the rear wheel, so they both use the same drivetrain to run it.

Some advantages of a hubmotor as middrive:
--Stronger wheel (longer spokes, etc)
--lighter wheel, easier to fix flats, etc (can also easily carry whole spare wheels if necessary to speed flat fixes)
--no special dropout hardware needed
--if gearshifting device (IGH, etc) is after motor in chainline, then motor gets advantages of being able to shift gears just like the pedals (and your legs) do; may need less motor (and controller/battery) to do the same work under some conditions
Some disadvantages:
--more complex, more things to align and tension in chainline
--chaindrive system wears faster
 
Back
Top