liveforphysics said:
Punx0r said:
Until the Model S demonstrates the endurance to lap a track like the Nurburgring Ring it's going to continue getting dismissed out-of-hand by the majority. I don't doubt Tesla will get there, it's just a case of when.
How many laps have you done on Nurburgring?
I'm going to guess somewhere between 0 and less than 10.
How many times have you accelerated away from traffic or a stop light or something?
I think in your rush to defend the EV you missed my point
The Model S might be making a big splash in California, but in Europe it's presence is non-existant. I've seen a handful of web-based reviews from the motoring press, but nothing on TV. It's not EV phobia: The Porsche 918, La Ferrari and McLaren P1 hybrids are getting plenty of airtime and generating a lot of interest. They are getting credit for bringing performance EV power to road cars, raising awareness and changing opinions. Where is Tesla, who we internet nerds know has achieved much more? Nowhere. No one's heard of them unless they're a car nerd.
Why is this? Several reasons, but I think a big one is that a typical car review on anything remotely sporty or performance-orientated involves some track testing. From what I've read, the Model S cannot complete a lap of most tracks without entering reduced power mode (which will invariably be called "limp mode"). The response from most reviewers? "What the frock is this?!".
Does it matter for average road driving? Unlikely. But then neither does top speed, 0-60 time, quarter mile, lateral g or any manner of other things. 99% what you need is economy, compact size, good all-round visibility and comfortable seats, because you're in traffic. However, 99% of people don't buy a car on those points. They want something fast, powerful and sporty, even if they'll likely never use that performance. It's evident from the EV range issue. Most people drive considerably less than 50 miles a day, but won't entertain the idea of an EV with less than 500 miles range.
The Nurburgring in particular is very popular proving ground and yardstick for many car manufacturers at the moment. It might be daft, but it's what people currently think is significant. If the Model S can't do it, then it will be dismissed without consideration by many people - as I said before.
The only 'Ring time I can find for the Model S is "about 10 minutes", bridge-to-gantry. The current record for a production EV is 7:56 (Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG Electric Drive).
In fact, here's what a 10 minute (10:08) lap "car" looks like:
Ford Transit van
Diesel
136 BHP
0-60 time: 21sec
In looking up some numbers for this post I found plenty of similar talk on the Tesla forum. The measure of a car being the traffic light GrandPrix is a North American phenomenon. Tesla needs to better understand its target market if it wants to make headway in the rest of the world. At least as long as it's using performance as a selling point.