Oh man.. I like to think i've tried it all.. but i keep finding better and better materials as i go..
Tool Box Liner - Comes in roles, spongy rubber, perforated, same as i used on the inside of my lexan boxes, 1/8th thick and it will not compress.. it stays spongy.. Also found in department stores for kitchen drawer ( sp? ) liners..
Crazy Carpet - Kits plastic sled sheets, you roll it out. sit on it and slide down snow hills.. dollar store..wall mart.. toys R Us
Foam in a Can - tricky.. but you can spray it into a box. let it harden and then cut it with a bread knife..
Door Mats !! ( seriously ! )
Peel and stick flooring tiles !!!