I was reading the A123 "Cylindrical Battery Pack Design, Validation, and Assembly Guide" document. It explicitly discourages mechanical fastening of cells on their ends. They discourage holding cells from their ends for two reasons, one because you cannot cover up the venting area of the cell and two because vibration transferred to the cell through the top/bottom shortens cell life. Below are relevant snippets from the document. The pack referenced in this link: http://endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=39980 would seem to violate A123's design criteria, but I haven't seen the inside of it. I can think of ways to mitigate these issues in a mechanical clamping design, but I am skeptical that this pack does it. Also, they claim it is waterproof, which is great but is there a way to vent the gas if a cell vents?
This is the A123 document: http://assets.buya123batteries.com/images/a123/Battery_Pack_Design_Guide_Rev_07.pdf
"Cell Support
Secure the cells in place by supporting their outside cases, not their terminal ends. The vibration induced between the terminal ends and the rest of the case has been shown to be detrimental to the life of the cell, causing internal and external cell damage. The intercell terminations must be light enough not to cause vibration-induced damage to the cell."
"Never use pressure at the top and bottom of the cell to hold cells together in a way that leads to blocked cell vents. If the vents are blocked, the gas cannot exit the cell in case of cell failure. Cells shall be mounted in the application, in a way that will not interfere with the vent function on the cell."
"Thermal Events
Proper battery pack design is essential to allow the safety features of A123 Systems’ cells to function as designed.As a safety feature, overheating A123 cells vent gases to relieve dangerous pressure buildup to disperse into the environment. However, an improperly designed battery pack can prevent the gases from safely dispersing, or prevent the cells from venting altogether.
Adding an ignition source to improperly-vented gases can create a dangerous thermal event. You must ventilate these expelled gasses from the environment itself after the gases are vented from the cell itself.
"