Allex said:
Offroader, looks like your findings about temp is similar to mine, here is the comparison chart that I made. 30Q stays much cooler at 7A per cell.
7A is pretty much a limit for GA. At 10A they do get way to hot if you need them to survice a long time.
Also take a look at what happens at 3V, 30Q gives you same amount of energy as GA.
https://0bb0688e10cd626d9cdaa22df789bdf0250ef581.googledrive.com/host/0B1sNQs8gfn7iZWVYMm85eFotcnM/30QvsHE2vsGA.jpg
Your internal resistance is 0(mohm), looks like you did not have a constant ride while holding at least 10Amps for 10seconds. I think your drive style is a lot of short bursts on full throttle and then no throttle at all. Do it next time you ride. Would be interesting to see how high your pack resistance is.
Today for some reason my temp probe temps stayed low. I think I may have a faulty probe so I need to place two probes into the battery to compare. The probe is placed into the very center of the pack through a hole I purposely didn't hot glue.
I still believe that my pack should stay cool because I am not drawing high continuous current from it. Max peak current I draw is around 7 amps.
Since my rides are over 2 hours to use about 2500 watt hours, That means I am averaging 1 amp on the cells the entire ride.
I don't know if you can predict temp based on average usage like this, but I am not by any means using 7 amps continuous for very long at all.
This is why I am going to need more testing to see just how hot my pack is getting, because it doesn't feel like it ever got that hot. If it really did get as hot as 50 C, my side covers would be very hot. My motor gets that hot on the outside and it is burning to the touch, I can feel the side of my battery pack through a hole in the top and it is cool.
Allex when comparing the samsung 30Q and Sanyo NCR18650GA, the SANYO does have more capacity. While that does look interesting that the Samsung 30Q can output the same capacity under load at a certain voltage, it is not fair to use.
The reason is, I base my capacity use not under continuous current, but on resting voltage. My ride stops at 3.3 volts, so at that point I will have used the full capacity up to that point which will be about 12% more than the 30Q.
The reason why the Sanyo NCR18650GA should work in my situation is because my pack is so large, 20S14P is a huge pack and my current draw requirements isn't that high. But this will be determined with more testing on how hot this pack is getting and how much capacity loss I have.
I am drawing a peak of 7 amps, but like I have said my average amp draw through my rides is around 1 amp. I think under these circumstances 3500 MAH cells should work.