oddjones
10 W
Thank you for this! - I've figured this, but when you get stuck in a gumption trap like this you start questioning everything you haven't got a definitive answer for!John in CR said:OddJones,
Sorry about the stupid post that I deleted. If you actually rode it, however slowly, the motor is mounted on the bike in the proper direction. Yes is should freewheel when you spin it forward (that's like you are coasting along or pedaling only, so you don't want the motor resistance).
Ahem... yeahNow to your problem. Am I to understand that you have it running fine with good speed and the motor sounding nice and smooth at all speeds, but it needs a little backward roll to get the controller to kick in? If so, then it sounds like your initial ride with the incorrect wiring did some damage to the controller. When an electric motor is sounding like the "crack of doom" and you keep going until "it made a really ugly noise and the motor cut completely", then I would consider you to be very lucky if you didn't damage at least the controller by riding it with the wires connected incorrectly.

Agreed - I've got a spreadsheet full of working combinations(!) ... Knuckles?John in CR said:If it's now running well and spinning the wheel forcefully, the the wiring sounds correct, but that little backwards roll requirement is saying that it first needs a magnet to pass a hall sensor to get going. Something is definitely wrong. My guess would be that you fried something in the controller. Since it still works at all, then it's probably something small. My suggestion would be to get with Knuckles and explain the symptoms and history to get the problem diagnosed, and get you riding. If it "goes great guns" with the motor no ragged noises, only the whirring of the gears, then the wiring sounds correct, so I hope you made note of the combination. Don't spend a bunch of time going crazy with wiring combinations until you have a diagnosis.
I've heard lots of mentions of torque arms on this forum, but I've not seen a picture or any links to where I might get hold of them? - this is a BIG forum with lots of posts to read - maybe a suggestion for the "getting started" section would be a glossary?John in CR said:Good Luck with it. All the frustrations will make it all the more sweet once you get it running properly. On my first ride with a hub motor, I made it less than 10ft before the dropouts snapped and the axle spun breaking the wiring harness, and I thought I had sufficient torque arms, so if it's just the controller you got off easy. I don't see torque arms on yours, and with a front geared hub that's just begging for a serious accident.
John - thank you so much for taking the time to read through my tribulations and come up with such a thorough answer - it's just what I needed - I woke up this morning thinking "Have I got to send my motor back to China?" (It took 2 months to get it here) - now I have a plan - starting with some PMs
Thanks again,
Dom.