steppe
1 mW
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2015
- Messages
- 14
Hi there, lurker over here with a project.
I've been meaning to do a build with a small motorcycle/moped with a bit more power to take me around town and do some errand running. I'm based in Mexico, so I can get parts from the USA, China and Canada without much fuss, but locally I'm not always that lucky. I can get industrial parts without problem (wires, connections, switches), but batteries and motors are somewhat limited.
I'm still in the planning phase but I've already got some of the motorcycle components and I'm going over some of the options regarding motor and batteries, and I'd love some help with this. (and a sanity check!)
To sum it all up, I'm looking to make something like riba2233's build (https://endless-sphere.com/forums/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=33118). riba, if you are reading this, I LOVE your build, I've been lurking your posts for info and analyzing all of your pictures to get all the information I can hahaha. His awesome build at EV Album: http://www.evalbum.com/4966
Another recent build that I like is spata's Honda MT50 conversion: https://endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=80785. Love the way the batteries are hidden in the frame.
I'll break everything down into categories to make it easier to explain what I want to do.
GOALS:
As I said I want this to be a small errand runner and maybe a small delivery bike.
Top speed: 30 - 35 MPH / 50 - 55 KPH
Range: Al least around 30 mi / 50 km
Loading weight: Around 265 lb / 120 kg including the rider. I want to be able to attach a case on the back for running errands/delivery.
It should be able to handle a couple of hills here and there, but I'm not expecting crushing performance or destroying tires.
FRAME / MOTORCYCLE / MOPED:
Right now I have a General Sachs 5 Star Moped / Lazer Sport with a junk engine (got it cheap!).
Not my photos:
Most delivery motorcycles around here are Honda CB100s frames with a 125cc (CGL 125) or 150cc (CGL 150) engine or chinese copies with 110/125/150cc engines, so parts for that kind of bike are easy to find.
I want to replace the front forks and rear swingarm with parts from those motorcycles to simplify service and open up tire and brake options. I have a bike mechanic that does quite good work, and I'm not afraid of modifying stuff myself.
My reasoning behind the General/Lazer frame is that mounting the motor should be easy with a plate on the original mount, and the "middle space" can be used for batteries, or modified accordingly.
Tires would be 17" or 18", between 2.50 and 3.00
MOTOR:
EDIT 2016-08-23: [I've since switched over to the Golden Motors 3kW 48V BLDC. Lighter, cheaper and batteries should be easier to find. I'll post a whole lot more about that motor once I get all my info gathered, but I'll leave this here so you can see how this project evolved.]
I've struggled a bit to find options since I don't really know a lot of suppliers. I've checked here on the forums and found some options, but I really want a supplier that can stand behind his product and that could respond if anything happens.
Right now I'm looking into a Golden Motor 5 kW BLDC (http://www.goldenmotor.com/eMotorcycle/frame-emotor.htm look for the 5 kW motor option). I've seen it mentioned a couple of times here and in some more professional builds like the Bolt M-1 (http://www.boltmotorbikes.com/)
I like the size, voltage flexibility and the fact that there's a company behind it.
I've seen Motenergy mentioned a couple of times here, but I'm a bit lost with their BLDCs (http://www.motenergy.com/brdcmo2.html).
Is 5 kW too much? Too little? Too heavy?
I'm still working on the voltage/current I should be running with. 48 V sounds nice and safe (I've had experience with ebikes and no problems there), but I keep finding that 72 V would be more efficient and draw less amps, so I'm still on the fence.
CONTROLLER:
A lot of posts I find here and other forums say to match your motor with a controller from the supplier if you can, so I've really only looked into the controller Golden Motors offers, the VEC300 (http://www.goldenmotor.com/eMotorcycle/frame-emotor.htm just under the 5 kW motor option).
Really no experience or comment here. I like the clean wiring diagrams and connections that they offer, but again, I'm open to opinions/suggestions.
I know about Kelly (http://www.kellycontroller.com/) and Adaptto (http://adaptto.com/Products/Controllers/), but don't really know what to look for here.
As a side note, I've been working on wiring diagrams with the Engineer Dog build over at Instructables. I think it's pretty well explained and very clean, with all of the safety measures it needs: http://www.instructables.com/id/Engineer-Your-Own-Electric-Motorcycle/
BATTERIES:
The big one. I'll break it down with what I've researched so far.
Voltage:
Using the Golden Motor 5 kW as example, it takes 48, 72 or 96 V.
I've worked with 48 V. I've felt pretty good around those batteries and I like that a lot of ebikes run at this voltage or 50 V. (Shout out to Paul at EM3ev, you rock!).
But 48 V draws more current than 72 V, and that takes a toll on battery selection.
From what I understand, the 5 kW motor draws:
1. 48 V: Curve http://www.goldenmotor.com/eCar/HPM48-5000Curve.pdf
* 74 A @ peak efficiency
* 176 A @ peak power
1. 72 V: Curve http://www.goldenmotor.com/eCar/HPM72-5000Curve .pdf
* 50 A @ peak efficiency
* 158 A @ peak power
Which takes me to the next step.
Current draw:
From what I see on the curves, the motor would peak at 180 A @ 48 V or 160 A @ 72 V.
That is a lot more than what my ebike draws.
I've been working on a little excel table to help me decide what works and how big it would be. I'll attach it and if anybody has any use for it, grab it, but please let me know of any error you find!
Range - Ah / Wh:
From my research, 100 Wh/mi seems to be a good estimate for motorcycles. Both the Engineer Dog and 300MPG builds are around that figure, but I'm running a lighter frame.
riba2233s build seems to be around 40 Wh/mi (lighter), and from his cell choice, voltage and C rate I think he is running 48 V @ 60 A with 29E cells. (14S16P). That's 2.8 kW on the motor, and a 2.2 kWh pack.
If I assume around 40 Wh/mi, and run with 48 V (or 50.4 V), I found a couple of interesting choices:
1. Samsung 30Q - 3000 mAh - 15 A:
* If I run the cell @ 10 A, I can get 50.4 V - 90 A in a 14S9P pack
* Up to 4.3 kW constant
* 27 aH - 1.3 kWh for ~34 mi / 54 km
* Paul @ EM3ev sells a pretty similar one for $915: http://em3ev.com/store/index.php?route=product/product&path=35_51&product_id=123 (BMS limited to 40A, but could check if it could be changed)
2. Samsung 25R - 2500 mAh - 20 A:
* If I run the cell @ 10 A, I get 50.4 V - 90 A in a 14S9P pack
* Up to 4.3 kW constant
* 22.5 Ah - 1.1 kWh for ~28 mi / 45 km (I could live with that)
* Paul @ EM3ev has one for $790: http://em3ev.com/store/index.php?route=product/product&path=35_51&product_id=123 (again, BMS limited to 40A)
3. LG MH1 / Panasonic BD - 3200 mAh - 10 A:
* Running @ 10 A, 50.4 V - 90 A in 14S9P
* Up to 4.3 kW constant
* 28.8 Ah - 1.4 kWh for ~36 mi / 58 km
* DIY or no idea where to get one
4. Panasonic GA / LG MJ1 - 3200 mAh - 10 A:
* Same 10 A, 50.4 V - 90 A in 14S9P
* Up to 4.3 kW constant
* 31.5 Ah - 1.5 kW for ~39 mi / 63 km (pretty good!)
* DIY or no idea where to get one
So what do you think? If I could get Paul to switch the BMS in one of those packs could it work? He also has some 14S7P and 14S8P that could work and are a bit cheaper, if I needed to test first or something.
What about running those high amp cells at a lower discharge rate? Better? Am I forgetting something here?
Should I make another post just for my battery questions?
I have no experience with LiFePO batteries, but I've seen some builds here with some of them, and I see Golden Motor sells them. I even added them to my excel to compare them, but still no clue. Any options there?
Also, I have very limited experience with LiPo batteries, but I would prefer to keep with known 18650s or LiFePO if I ever decide to take this to another level, mainly outfitting a couple of bikes for friends or to sell.
Since I know the battery is the most expensive buy here, I've been looking into DIY, but having no experience building packs, I don't know if such a big pack (100+ cells) is a good first project.
EXTRAS:
1. DC/DC converter: I can get an automotive-grade (weather sealed, good heat dissipation) for cheap here.
2. Lights: As I said, the Honda CB100 lights should be pretty easy to find.
3. Contactor.
4. Main battery disconnect.
5. Fuses here and there (full wiring diagram coming up).
6. Charger: Still on the fence if it should be on board or not.
7. Horn: I'd LOVE an attention grabbing horn, but that's for later.
8. Display: No clue what to do here. I'd love something that looks good and is easy to read, but for starters maybe a Cycle Analyst?
BUDGET:
I know it's not cheap, but I'm willing to shell out a bit more for good products and good sellers. Shipping/duties will probably kill me, that's why I'm gonna go junkyard diving for fixing the frame up.
Probably around $2,000 USD for everything, not including the frame that I got for $60. (Tip: Check some mechanic's yard; they're bound to have something interesting just rotting away waiting to get "fixed up" or sold to whoever asks first.)
Right now I want to check what the battery would end up costing to decide how I'm going to allocate resources.
Thanks a lot for reading my wall of text!
I've been meaning to do a build with a small motorcycle/moped with a bit more power to take me around town and do some errand running. I'm based in Mexico, so I can get parts from the USA, China and Canada without much fuss, but locally I'm not always that lucky. I can get industrial parts without problem (wires, connections, switches), but batteries and motors are somewhat limited.
I'm still in the planning phase but I've already got some of the motorcycle components and I'm going over some of the options regarding motor and batteries, and I'd love some help with this. (and a sanity check!)
To sum it all up, I'm looking to make something like riba2233's build (https://endless-sphere.com/forums/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=33118). riba, if you are reading this, I LOVE your build, I've been lurking your posts for info and analyzing all of your pictures to get all the information I can hahaha. His awesome build at EV Album: http://www.evalbum.com/4966
Another recent build that I like is spata's Honda MT50 conversion: https://endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=80785. Love the way the batteries are hidden in the frame.
I'll break everything down into categories to make it easier to explain what I want to do.
GOALS:
As I said I want this to be a small errand runner and maybe a small delivery bike.
Top speed: 30 - 35 MPH / 50 - 55 KPH
Range: Al least around 30 mi / 50 km
Loading weight: Around 265 lb / 120 kg including the rider. I want to be able to attach a case on the back for running errands/delivery.
It should be able to handle a couple of hills here and there, but I'm not expecting crushing performance or destroying tires.
FRAME / MOTORCYCLE / MOPED:
Right now I have a General Sachs 5 Star Moped / Lazer Sport with a junk engine (got it cheap!).
Not my photos:


Most delivery motorcycles around here are Honda CB100s frames with a 125cc (CGL 125) or 150cc (CGL 150) engine or chinese copies with 110/125/150cc engines, so parts for that kind of bike are easy to find.
I want to replace the front forks and rear swingarm with parts from those motorcycles to simplify service and open up tire and brake options. I have a bike mechanic that does quite good work, and I'm not afraid of modifying stuff myself.
My reasoning behind the General/Lazer frame is that mounting the motor should be easy with a plate on the original mount, and the "middle space" can be used for batteries, or modified accordingly.
Tires would be 17" or 18", between 2.50 and 3.00
MOTOR:
EDIT 2016-08-23: [I've since switched over to the Golden Motors 3kW 48V BLDC. Lighter, cheaper and batteries should be easier to find. I'll post a whole lot more about that motor once I get all my info gathered, but I'll leave this here so you can see how this project evolved.]
I've struggled a bit to find options since I don't really know a lot of suppliers. I've checked here on the forums and found some options, but I really want a supplier that can stand behind his product and that could respond if anything happens.
Right now I'm looking into a Golden Motor 5 kW BLDC (http://www.goldenmotor.com/eMotorcycle/frame-emotor.htm look for the 5 kW motor option). I've seen it mentioned a couple of times here and in some more professional builds like the Bolt M-1 (http://www.boltmotorbikes.com/)
I like the size, voltage flexibility and the fact that there's a company behind it.
I've seen Motenergy mentioned a couple of times here, but I'm a bit lost with their BLDCs (http://www.motenergy.com/brdcmo2.html).
Is 5 kW too much? Too little? Too heavy?
I'm still working on the voltage/current I should be running with. 48 V sounds nice and safe (I've had experience with ebikes and no problems there), but I keep finding that 72 V would be more efficient and draw less amps, so I'm still on the fence.
CONTROLLER:
A lot of posts I find here and other forums say to match your motor with a controller from the supplier if you can, so I've really only looked into the controller Golden Motors offers, the VEC300 (http://www.goldenmotor.com/eMotorcycle/frame-emotor.htm just under the 5 kW motor option).
Really no experience or comment here. I like the clean wiring diagrams and connections that they offer, but again, I'm open to opinions/suggestions.
I know about Kelly (http://www.kellycontroller.com/) and Adaptto (http://adaptto.com/Products/Controllers/), but don't really know what to look for here.
As a side note, I've been working on wiring diagrams with the Engineer Dog build over at Instructables. I think it's pretty well explained and very clean, with all of the safety measures it needs: http://www.instructables.com/id/Engineer-Your-Own-Electric-Motorcycle/
BATTERIES:
The big one. I'll break it down with what I've researched so far.
Voltage:
Using the Golden Motor 5 kW as example, it takes 48, 72 or 96 V.
I've worked with 48 V. I've felt pretty good around those batteries and I like that a lot of ebikes run at this voltage or 50 V. (Shout out to Paul at EM3ev, you rock!).
But 48 V draws more current than 72 V, and that takes a toll on battery selection.
From what I understand, the 5 kW motor draws:
1. 48 V: Curve http://www.goldenmotor.com/eCar/HPM48-5000Curve.pdf
* 74 A @ peak efficiency
* 176 A @ peak power
1. 72 V: Curve http://www.goldenmotor.com/eCar/HPM72-5000Curve .pdf
* 50 A @ peak efficiency
* 158 A @ peak power
Which takes me to the next step.
Current draw:
From what I see on the curves, the motor would peak at 180 A @ 48 V or 160 A @ 72 V.
That is a lot more than what my ebike draws.
I've been working on a little excel table to help me decide what works and how big it would be. I'll attach it and if anybody has any use for it, grab it, but please let me know of any error you find!

Range - Ah / Wh:
From my research, 100 Wh/mi seems to be a good estimate for motorcycles. Both the Engineer Dog and 300MPG builds are around that figure, but I'm running a lighter frame.
riba2233s build seems to be around 40 Wh/mi (lighter), and from his cell choice, voltage and C rate I think he is running 48 V @ 60 A with 29E cells. (14S16P). That's 2.8 kW on the motor, and a 2.2 kWh pack.
If I assume around 40 Wh/mi, and run with 48 V (or 50.4 V), I found a couple of interesting choices:
1. Samsung 30Q - 3000 mAh - 15 A:
* If I run the cell @ 10 A, I can get 50.4 V - 90 A in a 14S9P pack
* Up to 4.3 kW constant
* 27 aH - 1.3 kWh for ~34 mi / 54 km
* Paul @ EM3ev sells a pretty similar one for $915: http://em3ev.com/store/index.php?route=product/product&path=35_51&product_id=123 (BMS limited to 40A, but could check if it could be changed)
2. Samsung 25R - 2500 mAh - 20 A:
* If I run the cell @ 10 A, I get 50.4 V - 90 A in a 14S9P pack
* Up to 4.3 kW constant
* 22.5 Ah - 1.1 kWh for ~28 mi / 45 km (I could live with that)
* Paul @ EM3ev has one for $790: http://em3ev.com/store/index.php?route=product/product&path=35_51&product_id=123 (again, BMS limited to 40A)
3. LG MH1 / Panasonic BD - 3200 mAh - 10 A:
* Running @ 10 A, 50.4 V - 90 A in 14S9P
* Up to 4.3 kW constant
* 28.8 Ah - 1.4 kWh for ~36 mi / 58 km
* DIY or no idea where to get one
4. Panasonic GA / LG MJ1 - 3200 mAh - 10 A:
* Same 10 A, 50.4 V - 90 A in 14S9P
* Up to 4.3 kW constant
* 31.5 Ah - 1.5 kW for ~39 mi / 63 km (pretty good!)
* DIY or no idea where to get one
So what do you think? If I could get Paul to switch the BMS in one of those packs could it work? He also has some 14S7P and 14S8P that could work and are a bit cheaper, if I needed to test first or something.
What about running those high amp cells at a lower discharge rate? Better? Am I forgetting something here?
Should I make another post just for my battery questions?
I have no experience with LiFePO batteries, but I've seen some builds here with some of them, and I see Golden Motor sells them. I even added them to my excel to compare them, but still no clue. Any options there?
Also, I have very limited experience with LiPo batteries, but I would prefer to keep with known 18650s or LiFePO if I ever decide to take this to another level, mainly outfitting a couple of bikes for friends or to sell.
Since I know the battery is the most expensive buy here, I've been looking into DIY, but having no experience building packs, I don't know if such a big pack (100+ cells) is a good first project.
EXTRAS:
1. DC/DC converter: I can get an automotive-grade (weather sealed, good heat dissipation) for cheap here.
2. Lights: As I said, the Honda CB100 lights should be pretty easy to find.
3. Contactor.
4. Main battery disconnect.
5. Fuses here and there (full wiring diagram coming up).
6. Charger: Still on the fence if it should be on board or not.
7. Horn: I'd LOVE an attention grabbing horn, but that's for later.
8. Display: No clue what to do here. I'd love something that looks good and is easy to read, but for starters maybe a Cycle Analyst?
BUDGET:
I know it's not cheap, but I'm willing to shell out a bit more for good products and good sellers. Shipping/duties will probably kill me, that's why I'm gonna go junkyard diving for fixing the frame up.
Probably around $2,000 USD for everything, not including the frame that I got for $60. (Tip: Check some mechanic's yard; they're bound to have something interesting just rotting away waiting to get "fixed up" or sold to whoever asks first.)
Right now I want to check what the battery would end up costing to decide how I'm going to allocate resources.
Thanks a lot for reading my wall of text!