madin88 said:recently i had a conversation with a german battery manufactuer and i asked him why he only offers Sony and Panasonic cells, and not the LG HE2 or Samsung 25R for high power packs.
he answered the best cells come from Japan and the worst from China. The other asia manufacturers are somewhere in between. He have seen and got back many dead ebike batteries, but almost never packs with Sony or Panasonic cells and he assumes this is the same with the newer cells, but it also could be things have changed now.
in my cromotor bike i have a soldered 22s9p pack made of Sony VTC4. some of the cells got really hot when i was soldering the wires to the cans.
i was a bit afraid some could have beed damaged because of the heat, but after 60 full cycles and many cycles in the range of 40-70 to 90% without balancing the drift over the entire pack is still below 6mV (measured with Junsi Cell Log)
that shows the spreading and quality of those Sony cells is really outstanding.
can you provide more details about the problems Sony had?\/ampa said:Regarding Japan cells are all good. Nonsense. Sony 18650 cells had also problems in the past.
if some cells really got degraded (in my case that must be the p-bricks on which i soldered the wires to the cans), why it should not be noticeable in some kind of drift over entire pack between cylce 1 and cycle 60?Soldering to the can especially to the negative cell connection degrades the cell depending on heat input so u will maybe only experience a shorter pack life. Nothing measurable in the first 60 cycles.
what know how do you have with those cells or whats your job which makes you claim this?I would call your conversation partner not that bright. :lol: Maybe he just gets a big discount on these and than tells you something from the horse.
madin88 said:can you provide more details about the problems Sony had?\/ampa said:Regarding Japan cells are all good. Nonsense. Sony 18650 cells had also problems in the past.
Source: batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/safety_of_lithium_ion_batteriesSafety is a further concern, but this applies to all batteries. A one-in-200,000 failure triggered the recall of almost six million lithium-ion batteries in 2006. Sony, the manufacturer of these cells, said that on rare occasions microscopic metal particles may come into contact with other parts of the battery cell, leading to a short circuit than can cause venting with flame.
Soldering to the can especially to the negative cell connection degrades the cell depending on heat input so u will maybe only experience a shorter pack life. Nothing measurable in the first 60 cycles.
Maybe because all cells got basically the same heat damage.madin88 said:if some cells really got degraded (in my case that must be the p-bricks on which i soldered the wires to the cans), why it should not be noticeable in some kind of drift over entire pack between cylce 1 and cycle 60?
I would call your conversation partner not that bright. :lol: Maybe he just gets a big discount on these and than tells you something from the horse.
I personally had only real life experience with RC lipo, Lifepo4 and these 25R cells.madin88 said:what know how do you have with those cells or whats your job which makes you claim this?
No, definitely not. in each pack (i have 3 x 6s and 1x 4s), four cells from the p-group on which i soldered the wires to the can got 2-3 times hotter than all the other ones.\/ampa said:Maybe because all cells got basically the same heat damage.
oh, thats why you defend for samsung :lol:I personally had only real life experience with RC lipo, Lifepo4 and these 25R cells.