Spacey said:
The problem with an unbalanced pack is that the cells that are NOT out of balance tend to get held at 3.8 to 3.9v by the BMS until the rest of the pack catches up and each cell is held at 3.65v.
With a 20Ah pack the minimal 40ma balancing power of your average crappy BMS is going to take a LONG time holding the high cells at over 3.8v.
But I do have packs that have been left on the charger for over 2 years now (Headway packs) and still hold full AH discharge as they did when new. The BMS holds each 12S 1P pack at 43.8V which means each cell is at 3.65v permanently. Why do I do this? Because leaving them off the charger for days when not used causes the packs to go out of balance which would mean when charging the pack again some of the cells hit above 3.8v whilst the pack is balanced.
Lesser of the two evils.
Maybe I should set the charger to 42.96v which would be 3.58v a cell. Would this compromise the BMS at all?
If you're floating for a long time like that, I would back off the HVC to 3.6 or just below. What should happen during top balancing is that the MAX cells get held to 3.6-3.65 while the other cells catch up, and yes, this can take hours under normal circumstances. A severely imbalanced large pack can take weeks to recover if depending on the balancers to do all the work. However, if your pack noticeably gets out of balance after a good top-off charge in just a couple of days, you have VERY uneven SOH (state of health) among your cells, or some cells with very high self-discharge. You shouldn't be able to get that far out of whack that fast.
dh