Busettii BBS02 Claims and Description are innacurate/lies!

cell_man

100 kW
Joined
Dec 16, 2009
Messages
1,043
Location
Shanghai, China
We occasionally get emails from customers that are new to Ebikes, asking about this wonder 750W BBS02 with a special 16 mosfet controller and 1300W (used to claim 1400W if i remember right) that only Busettii offers. They saw it on Amazon. It can be bought here: http://www.amazon.com/Electric-Bafang-8fun-Version-Controller/dp/B00LGC3QIY/

I am sorry, but there are several stretches of the truth in this description and 1 complete and utter lie. Stretching the truth a little is not so unusual for many sellers, but i find the lies about their wonder 16 fet controller to be a step too far.

I just do not understand what is going through someone's mind to make this claim and it makes me think they do not have much of a grasp of the technical details of such parts (and they are full of it too, IMPO only of course). For 1 thing, it is a 3 phase BLDC controller, and such controllers simply do not use 16 mosfets. The least fets that can be used is 6, then 9, 12, 15, 18 etc are normal configuration. So what, they tagged on another Mosfet, just for the hell of it, or they are counting maybe some small SMD parts on the PCB as an extra mosfet or 7? They found time to completely re-design the BBS02 between their busy schedule of running an Ebike store, or their buying power meant 8Fun gave them this wonder controller for their exclusive use?

The Fact is, the BBS02 25A controller uses 9pcs of TO-220 mosfets and has done so for close to 1 year, prior to that they used just 6. the housing had to be modified to fit 9 fets, and it is a tight fit.

It is normal practice to rate motors by their rated mechanical output power. The BBS02 is rated 750W output power at 48V, it uses a 48V 25A max, controller.

48V and 25A makes 1200W (48*25) max input power to the controller. The claimed 1300W max output power is coming from where? Coming out of where, the motor or the controller? Must be the controller, right?? Also they must be using higher than standard supply voltage voltage to make that figure? 52V and 25A makes 1300W max Input Power for example. Is 1300W max output power an accurate description? Maybe but they means 54.6V and 25A (charge voltage for a 13S battery). which means 1365W IP which could be ~1300W controller Output power, assuming 95% controller efficiency.

So, I Can't say 1300W Ouput Power is an outright lie, but it is a dishonest description IMO and very misleading. We supply 14S batteries with a 58.8V charge voltage. Would it be right to state the BBS02 has a max power input power of 58.8*25 = 1470W? Or maybe i could say the controller is 95% efficient and call the standard 48V 25A BBS02 ~1400W Output Power (at least for a brief moment on a fresh battery).

Maybe i am wrong, maybe everything they claim is true, but I'm sorry, i just can't see it. Anybody with some technical understanding on these matters, please chime in and let us know your thoughts. If any of my statements are untrue, or you know otherwise, i am happy to be proven wrong. Ridiculous claims are 1 thing, but outright lies are another and Busettii deserve to be called out for this.
 
You’re not imagining anything Paul. Those folks have been shoveling the BS for a while now.

Revealing reads for those interested…

http://www.endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=29822

http://www.endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=25496&hilit=+Busettii
 
Ykick said:
You’re not imagining anything Paul. Those folks have been shoveling the BS for a while now.

Revealing reads for those interested…

http://www.endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=29822

http://www.endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=25496&hilit=+Busettii

I'm not surprised, not much gets by the ES crowd, and for anyone with half an idea about Ebikes, it is obviously BS.

I'm often asked about this special kit and it seemed like putting my thoughts in 1 place and letting others see them and comment on them too, was a good way to do it and it saves me from saying the same thing over again. i did a quick search on ES and didn't find much, but maybe i didn't use the right spelling for the search, Busettii is an unusual spelling after all.

Anyway, i don't want people to think I am out to attack competition. The claims made in that listing are over and above normal marketing flannel and the typical exaggerations that are very common, it deserves to be pulled IMO.
 
I am a long term customer of Amazon. Unfortunately one of their great weaknesses is a failure to monitor or otherwise regulate the legitimacy of the listing on their site. Fortunately Amazon has an excellent return policy but 'Caveat Emptor' should always be at the forefront of an Amazon's customer's purchase process.

Also note that the top rated review of this AMAZON vendor/listing reports that it is a SCAM (with 23 out of 25 positive votes for that review). The only other alternative is to contact Amazon Customer Service directly about this listing .... and that is a royal pain in the southern most region with a very limited hope for any positive action.

cell_man said:
... 48V and 25A makes 1200W (48*25) max input power to the controller. The claimed 1300W max output power is coming from where? ...
Possibly the same place the 55 Volt 1500 Watts is coming from in this listing:
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00NHFSQEC
Note that they are claiming 26 Amps (vs 25) and rounding up of course.

FYI: Busetti's web URL is http://www.busettii.com/index.html
 
I think we've already figured out here on ES, in years past, that Busetti is better spelled Bullshitti. ;) Good to know that hasn't changed. :/
 
amberwolf said:
I think we've already figured out here on ES, in years past, that Busetti is better spelled Bullshitti. ;) Good to know that hasn't changed. :/

Couldn't agree more.

I went back and did another search on Besettii and there really isn't anything much on the first page of results, it could easily be missed with a quick search, but with the name in the subject, this thread came straight up, top of the page and can likely easily be found by searching Google too. I am sure the kit is perfectly ok, just like the other same model kits that are available elsewhere, so it is not like they are selling anything bad or substandard. If they offer reasonable after sales, cool, it is not such a terrible crime to stretch the truth, but come on, a 16 fet controller! :? Do me a favour :lol:
 
LewTwo said:
Possibly the same place the 55 Volt 1500 Watts is coming from in this listing:
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00NHFSQEC
Note that they are claiming 26 Amps (vs 25) and rounding up of course.

FWIW my bog-standard 9fet BBS02 from GreenBikeKit has always pulled 26A when maxed.
I'm running 12S. No custom programming by me except I did lower LVC to 42v.
 
cell_man said:
I went back and did another search on Besettii and there really isn't anything much on the first page of results,
Might be the spelling. I used

Busetti*

in case it was with one "i" or two.

title only
http://www.endless-sphere.com/forums/search.php?keywords=busetti*&terms=all&author=&sc=1&sf=titleonly&sk=t&sd=d&sr=topics&st=0&ch=300&t=0&submit=Search

message text or title
http://www.endless-sphere.com/forums/search.php?keywords=busetti*&terms=all&author=&sc=1&sf=all&sk=t&sd=d&sr=topics&st=0&ch=300&t=0&submit=Search
 
cell_man said:
..... but come on, a 16 fet controller! Do me a favour
I requested a quote for price and shipping of one of their 16 Mosfet controllers. My guess is that they will not respond.
 
Back
Top