grrga said:
I made a few discharge tests with small discharge currents.
Start battery voltage: 4,2V
End of discharge: 3,0V
Very interesting data. The cell is not on dampfakkus and lygte-info - just the LG MH1.
Some points and questions:
More informative would perhaps be a stop at 2.7V or 2.5V (usual: "“Standard Discharge” shall consist of discharging at a constant current of 570mA to 2.5V." )
At 3.0V the curves are still rather flat! Particularly with higher currents you do not see the real content so.
The LG MG1 / MH1 as most NCA/NMC cells do not (as LG D1 or UR-FM or LiPo's ;
click) have that flat curves, which fall off sharply below 3.1V . They are designed for 2.7V typical BMS undervoltage stop.
The vertical distances (->"voltage sag") between the curves look rather irregularly spaced, though constant current steps of 1A or 0.5A . Is that really due to cell properties? How defined and how constant is the charge stop condition? What is the charge stop temperature about? (Temperature affects most the state-of-charge a voltage X, current Y).
Is the meter somehow calibrated against multiple multimeters or so - regarding current and voltage?
Is it a 4-point measurement, or are the resistance of the cables/holder/contacts subtracted? or how are the resistances of cables/holder/contacts?
Are the curves made with one and the same cell? starting from the very first cell cycle? Or did you do some 5 formation cycles before? The seemingly very first discharge @ 0.5A still shows that kind of out-of-factory memory effect - a complex shape below 3.6V storage voltage. At the beginning the capacity and the curve form may still change a lot - thus same formation cycles are good before doing comparative voltage sag measurements - and a repetition of the first discharge later or so to check for effects.
Most interesting would be if sb could do some cycling tests finally - like
this. But thats a lot of effort ... Measuring at ~ M/3 perhaps is good for testing cycle life - and is near to typical EV currents not too aggressive. M = max charge/discharge rating = 2.9A / 10A for LG MG1. Thus at 1A charge and 3A discharge.