E-Bike electronic basics

oVxrtex

10 mW
Joined
Jan 12, 2025
Messages
22
Location
Suburbs of Chicago
Hello, I'm trying to build an ebike, and I have most of it planned out already, however I've figured out that what I know about electronics is not nearly enough to actually get a good pick on what motor/controller to use. My build so far is using an Amorge 72v40ah battery pushing 250A nominal and 350A peak, with (most likely) a 3kw motor/controller set off of alibaba where I'll upgrade the controller down the line. I might also just buy a motor and controller seperately, which is what I want to ask about. My questions are listed below:

1. How do you figure out phase amps, what are they, and how do they affect the bikes total wattage, or power output in general
2. What's the difference between the amps coming out of the battery, and the phase amps
3. Does the motor get any of those non-phase amps?
4. What is wh defined as? I know it's the total energy stored in a battery (watt-hours) but what does it actually mean? Is it the amount of power a battery can put out in an hour, or how many continuous watts it can push out through an hour until it dies?
5. How would I pick out a controller based on the phase/line amps? I'm looking at a fardriver nd72360 because I've heard it's good, but all I see is the 360A phase and 170A line and I'm not sure if the 170 line is enough for my battery (question basically is: how do the battery amps get put into phase/line amps)
6. What would you recommend as a motor/controller for this build? (budget is $1200 + hopefully $200 shipping, - about 800 for the battery with shipping so its like $400 + the extra $200 for shipping right now).
7. On average, how much better does a controller get after doing a shunt mod, can it be done on a fardriver or sabvoton controller, and how many more watts/amps can a controller push than advertised (on average, or just for the one you recommend/the fardriver nd72360 if it's a good option).

I know my questions are hella confusing, sorry about that. I'm just really tired and confused right now lol.

Thanks for the help in advance :)
 
My build so far is using an Amorge 72v40ah battery pushing 250A nominal and 350A peak,

The battery doesn't push current, it supplies whatever is demanded by the controller/motor, which is based on the load placed on them by the rider control input vs the terrain/riding conditions.

It has a limit to the current it can supply, which is usually those current (A) ratings you've listed. That limit just has to be greater than the maximum your system will ever need from it under any possible conditions, so that you don't damage it or stress it, and so that it won't shutdown when you need it most.


I don't know the brand personally, but if it's like many of the "cheap" brands, there are various potential problems with their choice of parts to build it with and possibly methods of assembly. I know there are posts on the forum that come up in a search on the name, but I only skimmed rapidly to see if there were big thumbs up or down comments on them, and didn't read any of them--you might want to before buying the battery (if you haven't already).



with (most likely) a 3kw motor/controller set off of alibaba where I'll upgrade the controller down the line. I might also just buy a motor and controller seperately, which is what I want to ask about. My questions are listed below:
Any specific reason for Alibaba? Copied from a recent post I made in another thread:

It's usually a place you go to buy hundreds or thousands of something, not just one, so not all sellers there will even talk to individuals (vs companies), even if they have listings for single items. Some of them also may require you transfer money to them via wire and perform the sale outside alibaba, which gives you no protection. There are also no enforceable warranties....

Depending on your location and requirements and budget, and any seller limitations you have, there are probably better places to get whatever you need, if you provide us with that information.

Here's some other questions (also from that thread) you might consider, as well. I've answered the other questions you posted below all that:

If you're set on alibaba, we'll still need to know the details of what system you actually want, what voltage and capacity of battery, etc., to help you find a kit.

Bicycle? Motorcycle? Moped? Scooter? (people's definition of "ebike" can include any or all of those, but "ebike", component-choice-wise, is really "electric bicycle" in the meaning of a bicycle-class EV, meant to be usable via pedalling and/or motor...the other things are really motor-only and not intended to be pedalled, whether or not they have any attached).

Based on the power levels of your part choices so far, you are probably building a motorcycle, not an ebike. ;)

Speed required? Under what conditions?
Do you want a middrive, or a hubmotor?
Geared or DD Direct Drive hubmotor?
Do you want the bare hubmotor or one already laced in a wheel?
What size wheel? (diameter, width, axle type, dropout width, brake style, etc)
If middrive, what type? Bolt into custom-frame BB fixture? Slide into standard BB? BB width?
What features do you want the system to have? (there are many possible ways for it to work)
Do you need throttle operation? Grip? Thumb?
PAS? What type? Torque, cadence, on/off?
Assist levels?
Regen? On/off or variable?
Etc.


1. How do you figure out phase amps, what are they, and how do they affect the bikes total wattage, or power output in general
2. What's the difference between the amps coming out of the battery, and the phase amps
Phase amps are what the motor draws from the controller.
Battery amps are just the amps the controller draws from the battery.
PA can be higher than BA because the controller is a power converter, "same" watts in as out, but the form they're in is different, to provide the control to the motor necessary to do what the rider tells it to via whatever input controls you have.

3. Does the motor get any of those non-phase amps?
No, the motor is driven by the controller, not the battery, so it can't see battery amps.

4. What is wh defined as? I know it's the total energy stored in a battery (watt-hours) but what does it actually mean? Is it the amount of power a battery can put out in an hour, or how many continuous watts it can push out through an hour until it dies?
Wh is watt-hours. It's simply and only the capacity of the battery in relation to the nominal voltage (the average it has over the discharge curve). You could think of it as how many watts it could put out for one hour, so that half that power draw would last two hours, twice that power draw would last half an hour, etc, but it doesnt' tell you how many watts it can *actually* supply--that requires a completely separate rating.

The actual power it can supply (they don't push power or current) doesn't directly have anything to do with it's capacity rating.

You may have a 3kwh (3000wh) pack that is only capable of ever supplying 50 watts, depending on the cells used, their age, construction and interconnects, BMS if any, connectors, conditions it's being used under, etc. But it could supply that 50w for 60 hours.

Or you could have a 50wh pack that is capable of supplying 2500W, if it's got super duper cells, connections, etc in it. It would only last for about a minute before it was empty, though. (and it would probably get pretty hot; RC LiPo packs are occasinally used like this for tiny hobby cars/etc)


To be more confusing, there are terms like C-rate that use capacity in Ah to define the current output capability; that's usually only used with cells...so a 2C cell can safely supply 2x the amps that the cell is rated in Ah (A and Ah dont' directly have anything to do with each other, either, making it even more confusing, but you get used to it).



5. How would I pick out a controller based on the phase/line amps? I'm looking at a fardriver nd72360 because I've heard it's good, but all I see is the 360A phase and 170A line and I'm not sure if the 170 line is enough for my battery (question basically is: how do the battery amps get put into phase/line amps)
To really explain the BA to PA conversion, you'd need to read up on how controllers drive motors, and how they do their conversions internally; there are a number of threads here that go into that, but it isn't important unless you're wanting to design and build one.

The only thing that really matters is whether the controller can supply the current needed to make the torque the motor needs to do the job you need it to do.

The controller battery current limit is the limiting factor in your system, on purpose. It works backwards of the way you probably think it does, because the controller pulls amps from the battery, the battery doesn't push them, so you always want a battery with a higher A rating than the controller's battery A rating.


The process is:

You pick a motor that can handle the load you're going to put on it, that can spin as fast as you need it ot to drive the wheel at the speed you need, for the size wheel you're going to use and any reductions between motor and wheel (if it's not a hubmotor), that has the torque capability you need to accelerate at the speed you want to and climb the worst-case hllls against the worst-case winds on the worst-case terrain you have.

You then pick a controller that can supply the required current to drive that motor in the way you need it to, and can operate at a voltage that will spin the motor at the speed you need it to go, and has all the features you want it to have.

You then pick a battery of the right voltage to spin the motor at the speed you need to go, that doesn't charge too high for the controller's limits, and can supply more current (amps, A) than the controller will ever need, worst-case, and has enough capacity (Ah, Wh) to do that for the entire time you need it to do so to get the range you want.

Then you get into the details, after that.


6. What would you recommend as a motor/controller for this build? (budget is $1200 + hopefully $200 shipping, - about 800 for the battery with shipping so its like $400 + the extra $200 for shipping right now).
We cannot yet answer that question, as you haven't provided any info on what the bike must do for you under what riding conditions, worst-case. ;)

I recommend checking out the motor simulator at ebikes.ca to see how the system parts interact with your riding conditions, using the pre-set parts they have there. Once you have an idea of how it works, after playing with it for a while, you can custom-set parts up to emulate the motor/controller/battery you want to try, and see how they may work for your needs.

You might find you need far less, or far more, of each of them than you presently expect.

7. On average, how much better does a controller get after doing a shunt mod, can it be done on a fardriver or sabvoton controller, and how many more watts/amps can a controller push than advertised (on average, or just for the one you recommend/the fardriver nd72360 if it's a good option).

It doesn't really get "better", just less reliable, though you might be able to push it well past it's normal limits. If you mean how far past those limits you can push it? Depends on what you do to it and how you use it--you'll know when you've pushed it to far when you're buying it's replacement. :p

A shunt mod makes it impossible for the controlelr to protect itself, the battery, or the motor, because it no longer has any idea how much current is actually flowing, so it's much easier to blow things up that way.

Depending on the controller design there may be ways to do a controlled mod by changing the elecronics between the shunt and the MCU (see various posts by Fechter / etc about that process), but that just means *you* know how much change there is--the controller can't know; thats the point of the mod to push it beyond it's built in safety limitations.

Most controllers are made as cheaply as possible, so they barely have good enough parts and construction to do the job they say they can do...the cheaper they are (cost and construction) the more likely it is a shunt mod will push them past their abilities and blow something up--and that is most likely to happen at the moment you most need the extra power, and leave you with a fried system and a long walk home, or if it fails in traffic while you're trying to avoid something bigger than you are, it could be fatal.

Plenty of success stories, but plenty of "oops" ones too. :( I've had both. Some people just keep replacing the cheap ones they blow up doing this, some do it once and it keeps working.

I would recommend picking a controller (and motor, and battery) that is actually capable of what you need it to do, unless this whole thing is just for fun and nothing on it or about it is "mission critical" for you, and you have plenty of money to replace things that blow up. ;)

Almost always cheaper to buy right once than to re-buy insufficient multiple times.
 
Thanks for the response!
To answer most of your questions:

Speed required? Under what conditions?: As fast as I could go for this speed, I was hoping for 60 mph which I think I might be able to push, with a 3kw hub motor and a good enough controller (hub motors tend to have a ton of leniency when it comes to how much power they can handle, so I've heard/seen). Also the terrain is kind of flat, worth some very slight hills in most areas.
Do you want a middrive, or a hubmotor?: Mid drive would be nice, but they're too expensive so I'll just stick with hub until I can pick up a surron-style chassis.
Geared or DD Direct Drive hubmotor?: DD
Do you want the bare hubmotor or one already laced in a wheel?: I'm not sure if any professional equipment is required, so laced for now.
What size wheel? (diameter, width, axle type, dropout width, brake style, etc): 27.5in mtb with disc brakes, not sure what the width, axle type, or dropout size is right now but I'll look when I have a chance.
If middrive, what type? Bolt into custom-frame BB fixture? Slide into standard BB? BB width?
What features do you want the system to have? (there are many possible ways for it to work): I want to be able to turn the power up/down if necessary, not necessarily onboard but I just want the ability to do so (however it's not required).
Do you need throttle operation? Grip? Thumb? I'd like a grip throttle (full, not half)
PAS? What type? Torque, cadence, on/off? Not needed
Assist levels? Not needed
Regen? On/off or variable? Regen would be nice, especially variable, but it isn't a required feature for me.

The reason I want to use alibaba is because I've heard many good things come from certain companies on there, and the pricing is just so much better than the more mainstream motors/controllers (ex: nbpower 3kw motor is almost $300, and some 3kw kits with motors, controllers, displays etc. are $300).

Oh, also range, Id like it to be enough to last me like a day of riding (6 hours?) going around 25 or 30 mph a bit lower if necessary, which I'm guessing is pushing around 1kw right?

I'll also be able to pedal my bike, since it's a diy conversion, so if something breaks I won't be happy but it's fine since this build is mostly just to go fast & have fun :).

I've also heard many good things about Amorge, at least from the diy ebike community (not on here - mostly on YouTube & other places from smaller channels). They're based in China but people say they're highly reliable, and they actually have pretty good pricing so I might as well go for them 🤷‍♂️.
The only issue I have with them is that they aren't UL certified (which I need it to be so that I can charge it in my apartment, as per the lease agreement), so could you send over a couple recommendations of battery builders that could make a custom battery and have that certification? If not that's fine, I'll probably find a way to use Amorge in the worst case scenario.

So basically what I'm getting from the phase/line amps is that:
- The controller pulls the line amps from the battery, and converts it into phase amps somehow
- The phase amps then go to the motor
hopefully I'm correct on this :).

Thank you so much for your help!


Edit: if you need it I'll send a sheet with my bikes geometry as well once I have time
 
6. What would you recommend as a motor/controller for this build? (budget is $1200 + hopefully $200 shipping, - about 800 for the battery with shipping so its like $400 + the extra $200 for shipping right now).
Battery seems fake. They claim to use Lishen 2700 cells, that are spec’d at 4000mAh, 35A discharge. For a 40Ah, 72v pack, that would be 20s10p, or 200 cells. Wholesale price for those cells is around $5 (really cheap for a 21700 cell), so even at that suspiciously cheap price, you are at $1000 for the cells alone. Your budget is unrealistic. Either double/triple your budget, or greatly lower your expectations. I’d budget $2000+ for the battery on a 60mph bike.
 
Look at some builds from JB-360 and E-BikeGuy on YouTube, they use Amorge batteries often and they work really well, and I'm pretty sure they get them for cheaper.

Here's some lishen cells I found on alibaba (from a verified seller, for much cheaper than the $5-$6 you found them for)
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20250113-092232.png
    Screenshot_20250113-092232.png
    361 KB · Views: 3
Last edited:
Why are you asking? I'm not big on giving out personal information like that..
He's judging life experience and likely competencies, I reckon. Maybe also the degree to which your project might be seen as foolhardy, though that's not especially confined to any age group.
 
Last edited:
The battery doesn't push current, it supplies whatever is demanded by the controller/motor, which is based on the load placed on them by the rider control input vs the terrain/riding conditions.

I'd argue that voltage is "electromotive force" and that "push" isn't a far-fetched way to characterize that.
 
I can only have a certain amount of vehicles parked in my complex, people would get mad because of the loud engine, and I'd have to pay quite a bit for gas, so I might as well just get an electric bike. (also the power to weight ratio on these things are absurd)
 
Ya, it’s pretty low. 12kW is around 16 hp, which is why trying to go fast (for a bicycle), is expensive.
if I'm able to get the full potential out of the battery, I could be pushing 25.2 kw lmao (close to 40 hp, on a ~30lb bike disregarding motor, controller, and battery)
 
Nope, not at speed. The power and torque curves on an electric motor are descending, so nothing left on the top end.
With middrive motors does this improve? Also how much do you think it would be to build a surron-style bike (surron frame, middrive motor, forks, etc.)? I might do an off-road build in the future
 
With middrive motors does this improve? Also how much do you think it would be to build a surron-style bike (surron frame, middrive motor, forks, etc.)? I might do an off-road build in the future
Maybe a little, but even with 78kW, the electric Harley only tops out at 110mph. The characteristics of an electric motor are still the same (descending torque and power curves). You need to run higher voltages than 72V to get to 60mph, but doing that without wearing the corresponding protective gear isn't too bright.



Sell one of your vehicles to finance the bike.
 
The question is why? The risk vs reward for only going 105 mph on a bicycle is pretty high. You could do that in a Toyota Corolla. Get a real bike if you want to go fast.
 
I'm not planning on it (over 100 mph), but I'm just interested in the electronics and how it works, you know?

Maybe I could build a car someday in the future..
 
I'd argue that voltage is "electromotive force" and that "push" isn't a far-fetched way to characterize that.
Voltage isn't current, though which is what was being discussed. ;)

While there is a complex relationship between the (average) voltage placed on the motor by the controller and the current the battery can provide when drawn by the controller to do that, the battery doesn't push that current into the controller. That would imply that the battery would "overpower" the controller if it had a higher A rating than the controller did, which is the mistake made by many newbies to this (and other electronics) so they mistakenly get a battery with *lower* A rating than the controller has (endangering the battery with overload), which is what I'm trying to correct.
 
Oh, also range, Id like it to be enough to last me like a day of riding (6 hours?) going around 25 or 30 mph a bit lower if necessary, which I'm guessing is pushing around 1kw right?
Let's just assume it's only 1kw for that speed (it's probably going to be higher depending on your riding conditions, especially fi its' offroad--onroad you may have to deal with law enforcement). That means a minimum of 6kwh to run for 6 hours.

As an example of possible issues, a just under 3kwh pack made of 18650 cells that I'm considering for the SB Cruiser trike, capable of relatively high currents continuously, at 48v, is 35lbs essentially for just the cells and support frame (no enclosure), and is about 21x12x3 inches, a volume of about 756 cubic inches. This is about the kind of weight / density that any cylindrical-cell (18650/etc) pack would have (almost any pack you buy for ebike stuff is made of those or similar ones).

It would take at least two of those to give you 6Kwh to give you the range you want. So you would have over 70lbs of battery on the bike. Most of the batteries you can buy in those capacities from Alibaba / etc will be in a "brick" format, so some rectangle-like volume that you'd have to strap to the sides of the bike somewhere out of the way of your legs and pedals (you don't want to stick it on a rack, it'll break the rack or the frame the rack attaches to, but if you want to pedal it won't fit in the middle of the bike anywhere).

There are other cell types that are more dense, with no wasted air space in them, but it's still going to be a big brick or two you'd have to strap on somewhere.

Motorcycles have room in their frames for packs this big, and are made to have that kind of weight there, but bicycles aren't, so whatever you make out of one for the requirements you have is going to have to be a compromise between what you want and what will actually fit on there without breaking anything and without making the handling unrideable or unsafe.


I'll also be able to pedal my bike, since it's a diy conversion, so if something breaks I won't be happy but it's fine since this build is mostly just to go fast & have fun :).

Just a thought, but was your bike designed to go 60MPH? Brakes, suspension, frame itself? If not, consider what may happen when one of those things fails at that speed. :( I think there are some expensive downhill type bikes / parts built for those speeds, but if yours isn't one of those, you might want to reconsider that speed. ;)


The only issue I have with them is that they aren't UL certified (which I need it to be so that I can charge it in my apartment, as per the lease agreement), so could you send over a couple recommendations of battery builders that could make a custom battery and have that certification? If not that's fine, I'll probably find a way to use Amorge in the worst case scenario.
Right now, there are few UL-certified batteries, other than those that come with OEM prebuilt devices / bikes / etc. It's a very expensive process most trustworthy sellers can't afford***. The batteries that have been certified then have to be sold at higher prices because of this, to recoup the costs.

You can't just build a DIY pack and have UL certification, because they would have to submit it (in multiples, most likely) to UL for certification process. (it's not a company-cert, it's a per-device-design cert). As noted, that's expensive; my guess is that your battery would end up costing thousands to tens of thousands of dollars by the time you got it.

You will find many things labelled with CE, UL, and every other certification there is...but unless they can produce the certificate number and you verify with UL itself that it is real and actually for that specific product, it's almost certainly not certified. And there are degrees of UL certifications, as well, so you would have to be sure the product's certification matches that required by your apartment / etc.

So your battery is not going to come from Alibaba or Aliexpress, etc, almost certainly, if UL certification is a requirement. Neither will the charger.

I don't know of any place that sells a UL-certified battery large enough for what you want to do, so you will probably have to buy several and install a cradle for each one on your bike so you can use them all at the same time in parallel.

Check out ebikes.ca for some UL certified batteries. They probably won't run your bike, though. (unless you parallel several).


So basically what I'm getting from the phase/line amps is that:
- The controller pulls the line amps from the battery, and converts it into phase amps somehow
- The phase amps then go to the motor
hopefully I'm correct on this :).
More or less. But as noted, it doesn't matter for your purposes. ;)



***and the others aren't going to spend money on anything like that even if they had it, probably neither will any of the trustworthy ones that aren't required by law to do it, it could greatly reduce their profit margins.
 
As an example of possible issues, a just under 3kwh pack made of 18650 cells that I'm considering for the SB Cruiser trike, capable of relatively high currents continuously, at 48v, is 35lbs essentially for just the cells and support frame (no enclosure), and is about 21x12x3 inches, a volume of about 756 cubic inches. This is about the kind of weight / density that any cylindrical-cell (18650/etc) pack would have (almost any pack you buy for ebike stuff is made of those or similar ones).
That’s a gigantic battery pack though, maybe I could go for some LiPo batteries if you have any recommendations (or any other chemistry that’s got good energy density).

Just a thought, but was your bike designed to go 60MPH? Brakes, suspension, frame itself?
I’m not sure exactly the speed I want to go, but I do know that I’d like to be able to keep up with roads in my area (with people speeding as well). Most of the roads are pretty big, with 40-45 speed limits, some even at 50 without being considered a parkway or highway O-o. I know that it’s super unsafe, but it’s just something I’ve been looking forward to having considering there’s little to no possibility of having a dirtbike or motorcycle. If you have any recommendations on what I can do to improve the safety I’ll greatly take those :).

Right now, there are few UL-certified batteries, other than those that come with OEM prebuilt devices / bikes / etc. It's a very expensive process most trustworthy sellers can't afford***. The batteries that have been certified then have to be sold at higher prices because of this, to recoup the costs.
Well that sucks.. I might be able to work something out with my landlord if it has the european certifications (as stated in a previous post, I think).

I recently (pretty long ago, like 6 months but still..) saw a build from CalTheCool who used retired Tesla battery cells to make a 10kw build, and I’m thinking of doing the same thing, I just don’t know where to source them from. Let me know if you have any recommendations for that either :).
 
That’s a gigantic battery pack though, maybe I could go for some LiPo batteries if you have any recommendations (or any other chemistry that’s got good energy density).
6kWh is going to be huge and heavy for a bicycle-sized EV regardless of the cells you use.

You'll either have to require less range / time or greatly decrease power usage (much lower speed, better aero, much lower power system, etc) or both to use a really small battery pack.


Well that sucks.. I might be able to work something out with my landlord if it has the european certifications (as stated in a previous post, I think).
Regardless of labelling, the cheap stuff from china (or anywhere else) isn't almost certainly not actually certified anywhere. Ask them for the certificate for their specific product, then check with the actual regulatory agency it's from to verify that it is real. Without that confirmation, you can safely assume that it's uncertified, regardless of claims to the contrary.

Honesly that's probably true of just about every claim most of these sellers make about any property or specification of what they are selling, but most especially true for anything that adds cost.


I recently (pretty long ago, like 6 months but still..) saw a build from CalTheCool who used retired Tesla battery cells to make a 10kw build, and I’m thinking of doing the same thing, I just don’t know where to source them from. Let me know if you have any recommendations for that either :).
Doesn't matter what cells they are--if you need more capacity you need more cell volume to hold it, and that is larger and weighs more.

As for sources, I already linked a trustworthy source of used EV cells. There are others out there too if you poke around, though I don't know any others with free shipping for some of their products--just that one.

If you want to get into building your own battery from a lot of small cells, you should probably learn as much as you can about the process, pitfalls, tools, and parts needed first. I recommend reading the many good battery build threads here in the battery technology subforum, as well as those about testing cells, and those about the various connection methods and spotwelders, etc. It's a lot of info that you'll need. A lot of work to actually do, and could be a lot of time to fix the problems the first build will likely have.

I chose to avoid most of that by using the large-format EV grade cells that just bolt together; they work better and for longer (mine are now nearing a decade and a half old and beginning to really show that--if they were a bunch of small cells like 18650s/etc they would probably have worn out / had problems long ago and had to be replaced, but I've had almost zero problems with these ex-EV batteries).

I also choose that when I replace them, I'll be using one or more of the prebuilt ex-EV modules like those I linked (or others in my recent posts in my SB Cruiser thread here:
so I can pretty much just hook up the main + and - to my system and go. ;) There are some modules that would require more work to use, but if I use an ex-EV module, even if it's made of a bunch of small cells, I don't have to connect them all up, or worry that they are mismatched and have to test all the individual cells, etc--I can use them as they are. (I just don't look at the modules that would require disassembly and reassembly to use, unless they're like the cells I have now that just bolt together in a few minutes, instead of days or weeks or months of detail work to get a reliable long-lasting battery I don't have to worry about).


But, if you prefer, you can take apart any of the modules these places sell, and build your own completely custom pack from the individual cells, however you want to. It's just a lot more work and time, and money for all the tools and supplies to do it.

Also, while the ex-EV modules are almost certainly not individually CE or UL-certified, you may be able to use their professional big-name-car-factory origin to get your landlord to accept their presence, whereas it might be harder with a completely DIY pack or a cheap blue-heatshrink China firebomb special. ;)

Some of the modules some of these places sell come from server power-backup systems, and those may actually be CE or UL certified, and may even have this information printed on them, or at least on the system they come to you in (usually a rackmount box).
 
Voltage isn't current, though which is what was being discussed. ;)

While there is a complex relationship between the (average) voltage placed on the motor by the controller and the current the battery can provide when drawn by the controller to do that, the battery doesn't push that current into the controller. That would imply that the battery would "overpower" the controller if it had a higher A rating than the controller did, which is the mistake made by many newbies to this (and other electronics) so they mistakenly get a battery with *lower* A rating than the controller has (endangering the battery with overload), which is what I'm trying to correct.
That's fair. Controllers actively limit current, so it's not like a fixed resistance load.
 
That's fair. Controllers actively limit current, so it's not like a fixed resistance load.
And for the benefit of other readers coming along, a basic very cutdown explanation (much more and you get into math that I don't do):
They don't just limit the current, they transform it from the single battery voltage and current supply into a three phase "rotating" waveform (which FOC controllers directly manipulate via PWM based on the phase current sensors, and common trap/sine controllers regulate by simple PWM based on the battery current sensor) on the three phase wires of the motor.

(a brushed controller does a more direct current limiting and motor modulation by simply PWMing the votlage on the single pair of wires from motor to controller; it's much simpler than the 3phase BLDC types).
 
Back
Top