Do you know what a 'GoFer pitch' is?
Someone too embarrassed to say this in public said:
You know, opposing higher minimum wages is just believing that the working poor should subsidize (with their labor) the living standards of those who aren't poor. Is that fair?
You know, people ask questions without putting any thought to the words coming out of their mouths. Is that fair?
How in the world could someone concoct such a foolish notion? WHOSE living standards is the minimum wage worker subsidizing? The McDonald's workers -- WHY are they NOT making minimum wage in Beverly Hills subsidizing the lifestyle? Why do they insist on travelling there to make considerably MORE than minimum wage when they could stay close to home and make minimum wage at the same job? WHY do they refuse to subsidize the lifestyle of the poor by working close to home? Certainly the knowledgeable expert who cooked that questionable statement up realizes that fast food is criticized for being a cheap alternative to grocery store food in poor neighborhoods. Oh, are they making minimum wage in poor neighborhood grocery stores, too? Not in Beverly Hills, they're not. Clothes stores, whatever. You're not making minimum wage when you're working in the rich neighborhood, it's when you're in the poor neighborhood. Subsidizing the lifestyle of the poor, the welfare recipient, etc. If nobody works there for minimum wage, the prices go up, the stores close.
According to the U.S. government there are an average of one million people working full time for minimum wage. Maybe a half percent of adults. It's not clear in the study if that includes states such as California that have a higher minimum wage. Let's compare that to the dentists. Approximately 125,000 of them at any given time. Who's combined income is larger? They're about the same, actually, the dentists total only slightly more than 8 full time minimum wage workers. Is that somehow not fair? Are you saying that 8 minimum wage workers put as much into career development as a single dentist? That the 8 equal one dentist to ethical and professional standards? (PLEASE show some small dignity and concede the truth.) Do you really think there's any way to have the dentists work so hard to maintain those standards without the higher standard of living as the reward?
Meanwhile, let's move on to Wall Street. I know how much you love kicking around imaginary people from there. Let's discuss the real thing instead. So the commission workers. Are there as many of them as dentists? More, actually, it ranges around close to 200,000. Are there combined paychecks as much as the smaller number of dentists? A little, but in fact it averages out to a bit less apiece. (GASP!) I know, it hurts to think about them not making more, doesn't it? But why do you think that, again, you can have the professional and ethical standards that in their own way are just as important as those of dentists (Unless you LIKE the idea of jobs, businesses, retirement accounts, etc., disappearing overnight) If there's no money to be made at it? And what about all those local vendors paying people MORE than minimum wage so the service will be good in such a great location? Why are all those employees refusing to subsidize the lifestyles of these Wall Street types? And why is it okay with these Wall Street types that those people are refusing?
The problem with rhetoric is that it's, in a word, rhetorical. People spout things that don't hold up to scrutiny. The afraid to be the op should have put the question in the 'Weasel Words' post, because the entire premise is the definition of weaselly. Before the economy went bad you could get 2 years of college in California for $2,000 or less. Oh, you could get it not just free, but you could get grants to make a profit on going to college. Actually that's still true today, but it's at $5,000 or less. All of these semiskilled jobs that go unfilled because people can't be bothered to learn how to do it, they'd just rather complain about making minimum wage. Don't even get me started about seriously skilled jobs like welding that pay really well. Which you can also learn to do for free. Explain to me why someone unwilling to put anything into anything deserves our love and support. This is going to require a really good explanation.
Oh, I know, the real answer is, of course, socialism. As they proved in China, by forcing people to go to the countryside so there'd be cheap labor for the farms. A few weeks out of the year. By refusing the countryfolk the free healthcare and free education that was available in the city because they didn't have the ID card to belong there, they were able to keep the cost down for the people who did get it. Yeah, that socialism. It's always so --- FAIR. Like when the government built still mills out in the country so the unemployed countryfolk could work unpaid instead of sitting around. Mao needed weapons of war, afterall. Wouldn't even let them take two weeks off to go pick when the fields were ripe, (Once there was enough food to take for the cities) repeat offenders trying to get unharvested food from the fields were executed. THIS was the real cause of the Great Famine. Yeah, socialism has got it all figured out. They had the 3 'Have Nots.' No job, no shelter, no future. A huge percentage of the population was said to be 3 have nots. Yeah, socialism has it all figured out.
Read Chen Guangcheng's book, 'The Barefoot Lawyer.' In rural China a barefoot lawyer is someone without a real education who figures out how to protect the 2nd class citizens from the government. Cases that a trained lawyer wouldn't touch if the defendant HAD money to pay him. You'll develop a whole new RESPECT for forced equality.
A 'GoFer Pitch' in baseball is when the pitcher just hangs the ball there perfectly for even a weak batter to hit it out of the park. I have not yet begun to tee off on this subject. But I'll wait and see if there's another GoFer getting hung out there.
OK - So are you referring to the island in Micronesia or "Nehru" as in jacket?
Or the village in Tanzania, or did he mean Nauvoo? Gonna join the Coho Legion?