izeman said:
i don't want to hijack that thread, but could someone answer me how that bms lite differs from the smart bms - in case you don't install the celllogs of course, and use it as a "normal" bms. this is no offense, but i'm quite new to all this and don't see much difference, and this is only $24.
http://www.bmsbattery.com/smart/330-lifepo4lithium-ion-smart-bms-for-513-cells-in-series.html
does your board allow more current? is it more precise? is it safer to use? ...
i'd really like to buy one, and in the end i'll most probably will buy both of them
This so-called "smart" BMS is typical of the import designs, which have low balance currents, and have a discharge limit. You can, of course, simply bypass the output FETs, and maybe figure out how to tap off a signal that could be used to pull down the throttle signal, or you could simply use this as a balancer, and use something like methods' LVC boards for the LVC function. Even as a balancer, though, this has a woefully low balance current capability of only 50-60mA. Even with LiPos, this will take quite some time to balance even a healthy pack. In comparison, our latest Zephyr BMS provides about 500-600mA of balance current. That is ten times what this will do.
The Zephyr also has a "smarter" charge control scheme that will throttle the charge current back, when needed, to allow weak and/or grossly imbalanced cells a chance to automatically balance with the rest of the pack. We also have a very effective end-of-charge cutoff function that turns off the charge current completely when the cells are full and balanced. The Zephyr charge controller can also handle much higher charge currents, like 20, 30 or even 50A, if needed, and is expandable to support virtually any pack configuration, up to 300V+
The "Lite" version has exactly the same feature set, including the LVC function, but has a lower amount of balance current, so that these boards can be embedded in with the packs, without the need for an aluminum box, which acts as a heatsink for the higher current full Zephyr BMS units. Even still, the Zephyr Lite boards will handle at least twice the balance current of that BMSBattery import model. The charge controller uses the same circuits, but it is packaged to go in a small box. You have just two input wires, from the charger/supply, and a single output harness that has the main charge current wires, and the control signals going to the embedded BMS boards. These boards also act as parallel adapters, which simplifies pack connections.
It is more expensive, yes, but you get what you pay for, in my opinion.
You will be able to save money, though, by building them yourself, if you have basic soldering skills. They are not that hard to build.
-- Gary