This is my ass hatchet collection. They get more comfortable from left to right, except the new one on the far right is yet untested. The one on the left is my stock Bomber seat made by SDG. It should of been STD because after about 2 minutes a sexually transmitted disease would be preferable between your legs. It's by far the most uncomfortable seat of the bunch. At least it has acceptable looks, and does work as a seat so I give it a 1 out of 10.
Next in my collection is a seat made by Velo. It came on a Cadillac branded bicycle made by Kent bicycles. It's slightly more comfortable than the SGD, mainly because it's wider, and has more padding. It feels like it should be more comfortable then it is, but it isn't. The combination of it's shape, and size just didn't work very well for me. It's also a little style limited with a Cadillac logo in the middle of it, so I give it a 2 star rating.
The third seat is an Origin 8, Classic. It's noticeably more comfortable than the first two because it has a superior shape that works. It a little more saddle like. The Classic is a $20 copy a high dollar seat that looks just like it. It's a decent looking seat with a good shape, but where it comes up short is in the padding department. It has thin padding, and under that the seat pan is rock hard. Even so this seat is comfortable for a lot longer then the first two. I might still be using it on my Bomber, but even though it's a pretty decent looking seat, It's styling is a little too classic for the Bomber's modern avant-garde look. I give it a 4 out of 10.
The 4th seat is an expensive snooty ass $200 Brooks Cambium. Yeah I have to admit it's a little more comfortable than all the ones so far, but not by much. Since the top is a hammock design made out of thick rubber, it's softer than the others, but that doesn't mean it feels soft. It's pretty hard actually, but has more give where it needs it. It's not a whole lot more comfortable than the Classic, but it is more comfortable. Looks wise it's a combination between modern, and classic. I didn't feel like it fit with the Bombers Styling much better than the Classic. It's main problem though was pretty bad. The rubber top started tearing in at least 2 places, and would have gotten a lot worse if I hadn't taken it off when I did. I was kind of fat at the time, probably 235. Hey I'm under 200 now so stop laughing. Even overlooking that failure I still only give the Brooks a 5 out of 10, because it's really not that comfortable, and the looks weren't quite right for a Bomber.
That just leaves the last seat on the right. Made by Bontrager. I think it was a oem seat for some Trek model, made by Bontrager. It was $30 shipped. Haven't installed it yet so I can only comment how it feels in hand, but I like the way it looks. It's about as wide as the Cadillac seat, not quite as much padding, but the shape looks a little more comfortable. It's not flat like a skillet, it tapers down a little towards the sides. It almost could be a cross between the flat Cadillac seat, and the more rounded saddle Classic, but it has complimentary modern to a Bomber. I have high hopes for this seat.