TriggerGee said:
Lithium would be nice but can you imagine the cost of a 24v 70+ Ah lithium pack!
Except...you don't need a 70Ah pack, with Li. The reason you need such a pack with the lead is that you only get to use a portion of that energy.
Trouble is it uses an awful lot of power to just move as its 150kg so on a smooth flat it uses around 10-15A to travel at 8mph.
I know you give the actual trip info later, but:
So then let's say 30A just to be pessimistic and including slopes or rougher ground.
10 mile trip? 8mph? so let's say 1.5 hours of runtime. So, 45Ah would do it with some to spare, if using a chemistry that allows you to actually get all the power out of it that you put in.
My guess is you need even less than that, but you'd have to measure the actual used Wh to find out, with a wattmeter, on a few of your trips, to get a good average and max.
24V (28V really) @ 45Ah shouldn't be that expensive a pack, depending on what you use for it. Doesn't even need high-C-rate cells, depending on how much power the motors draw on startup and acceleration from a stop and how often you have to do that.
The bms tells me to charge once I've used 27Ah, my journey usually uses about 20 Ah.
So if you assume you need at least 30Ah to account for nonstandard trips and pack aging over time, you still don't need even half of the pack you have now.
That makes it even cheaper than the "guesstimate" I made above would.
To fraise it another way, can three 12v 73Ah batteries be connected somehow to give 24v and more Ah or am I being a plonker?
Not unless your controllers can work on 36V (40+V really), which is unlikely, because you'd ahve to wire tehm all up in series with only three.
Or if your controllers can work on 12V (14V), also unlikely, if you wired them all in parallel.
You can only use more batteries in sets of 24v (28v) in parallel with your existing 24v.
If you have to spend money on another battery anyway, why not just stick it in a piggy bank until there's enough to buy a complete replacement for the aging lead?
(note that the lead is also ballast weight on that vehicle, so if you actually remove it it may tip over on terrain it did not before, so you might have to leave it on there even when using a lithium battery...or, you could carry cargo, tools, etc., down low instead of the lead, if it was enough weight to ballast it).