Choosing a new controller, adaptto replacement

kdog

🚴‍♂️ Mega poster
Joined
Feb 2, 2014
Messages
728
Location
hobart, tasmania
Hi everyone
It's been along time since I've needed to buy a new controller, since most of my existing gear has lasted a long time.
I've built a scooter running a 3000w hub motor and it has been ticking along quite nicely on my old adaptto midi-e, but it died suddenly.
I need a new system that can perform similarly. So the must haves are:
5-8000w ball park power
Variable regen is a must have (I live in hills)
Safely run 84v
Display- preferably plug and play for this.
Bluetooth with phone app would be desirable
I don't want an overly complicated system (my life is busy enough at the moment😄)
I'd like to keep the price to around $500aud
I've looked at
Nuclear... Great but too pricey
ASI... also look great but afaict they max out at 75v
Fardriver ... seem to have only on/off regen, please let me know if this is incorrect
Sabvoton, kelly, kt and a bunch of cheaper controllers all have various issues, like no regen, poor reviews, or too low power or max voltage.
So I'm leaning towards a spintend vesc based controller which seems to fit all my requirements.
Before I drop the coin, anyone got any suggestions on something I may have missed
TIA
Kdog
 
This is an unfinished pic but you'll get the idea.. It's a blast to ride
 

Attachments

  • PXL_20260708_004733266.jpg
    PXL_20260708_004733266.jpg
    5 MB · Views: 14
Before I drop the coin, anyone got any suggestions on something I may have missed
Looks like a fun machine.

How familiar are you with the Vesc ecosystem?

Spintend is probably the sweet spot for budget Vesc based controllers.

Vesclabs(Link) is Benjamin Vedder's company, and makes some very high quality controllers with customer support to match.

I have an extensive list of Vesc based controllers if you are interested.
 
It is super fun to ride, I take it everywhere I possibly can. I'm not familiar with VESC at all other than the research I've been doing on controllers in general. I have reasonable general knowledge of motors and controllers so hopefully that will help.
Your list of controllers?... What do you mean by that?
 
It is super fun to ride, I take it everywhere I possibly can. I'm not familiar with VESC at all other than the research I've been doing on controllers in general. I have reasonable general knowledge of motors and controllers so hopefully that will help.
Your list of controllers?... What do you mean by that?
Some more VESC compatible controllers:

Teamtriforce (UK)
TeamTriforceUK

ENNOID: (Canada)
Home

Powervelocity Nextgen: (California)
24F NextGen PV Controller 144v
ES thread:
PV NextGen FOC 100-180v 36kw max - $799

JetFleet: (Slovenia)
jetfleetstore.com

Spintend: (China)
https://spintend.com/collections/esc-based-on-vesc

Makerx-tech: (China?)
Go-FOC

Or if you really want some juice:
Masinaelectrica/joulemotors(Netherlands)
100-200kW continuous:
Joule Motors
Brushless motors, 3Phase inverters, schematics. Joulemotors.com
Youtube-iulian207

I'm slowly working on getting a complete list put together.
 
I guess trampa still makes controllers?
Vesc labs have already been mentioned I think, Benjamin Vedders new brand.
3shul from India.
 
Back
Top