I think I might have something to contribute to this tread.
I've tried both belts, 25 pitch chains and even got a plastic chain.
Belts a great when it comes to zero maintenance, but considerably lossy when it comes to small pulleys and need pretention, and very careful alignment - or you'll get even more losses and skipping.
Chains, *waxed* chains that I use, are pretty much as durable as belts, also need extremely little maintenance (once very 1000 miles or so), are much more tolerant of misalignment and need no pretention, BUT are *NOISY*.
Plastic chains are actually no less noisy (plastic rattles quite a bit), but supposed to need no lubrication... low load rating, but that is not a problem for me, I do not need insane power.
And than I've had an idea - how about cogs *overmolded* with rigid, but still damping enough TPU?
I've already 3d printed me a 12T cog for my 'crank drive'/pedal generator (bicycle singlespeed chain) and it actually last for quite a while (about 1000km) before one of the teeth gets sheared - and I can output 500+ watts in my training sessions.
By using a composite cog with a steel 'core and 3d printed in 'vase mode' layer of TPU gluded to it, it might actually be the best of both worlds.
I've already 3d printed a cog entirely of TPU and it even kind of works at lower powers, but than skips not unlike a belt (cog remains intact). It does do a fine job of damping chain noise, so the idea has merit I guess.
I'll try with a 3d printed 'core' for now, I fear it will get sheared pretty fast, but might just work...
I've tried both belts, 25 pitch chains and even got a plastic chain.
Belts a great when it comes to zero maintenance, but considerably lossy when it comes to small pulleys and need pretention, and very careful alignment - or you'll get even more losses and skipping.
Chains, *waxed* chains that I use, are pretty much as durable as belts, also need extremely little maintenance (once very 1000 miles or so), are much more tolerant of misalignment and need no pretention, BUT are *NOISY*.
Plastic chains are actually no less noisy (plastic rattles quite a bit), but supposed to need no lubrication... low load rating, but that is not a problem for me, I do not need insane power.
And than I've had an idea - how about cogs *overmolded* with rigid, but still damping enough TPU?
I've already 3d printed me a 12T cog for my 'crank drive'/pedal generator (bicycle singlespeed chain) and it actually last for quite a while (about 1000km) before one of the teeth gets sheared - and I can output 500+ watts in my training sessions.
By using a composite cog with a steel 'core and 3d printed in 'vase mode' layer of TPU gluded to it, it might actually be the best of both worlds.
I've already 3d printed a cog entirely of TPU and it even kind of works at lower powers, but than skips not unlike a belt (cog remains intact). It does do a fine job of damping chain noise, so the idea has merit I guess.
I'll try with a 3d printed 'core' for now, I fear it will get sheared pretty fast, but might just work...