Optibike mid drive

Regarding throwing a bigger more powerful motor on the optibike...

Does anyone have any predictions if the rohloff could even handle that much power?

Maybe opti is limiting power not for legal reasons but for drivetrain limitations.

Its really sad to me that opti doesnt put a bigger motor on this thing....a 40mph 12 thousand dollar bike, lighteweight and clean, would make more sense to everyone. I bet then even some sphere members would own one.
 
YEP.
 
extremegreenmachine said:
Regarding throwing a bigger more powerful motor on the optibike...

Does anyone have any predictions if the rohloff could even handle that much power?

Maybe opti is limiting power not for legal reasons but for drivetrain limitations.

Its really sad to me that opti doesnt put a bigger motor on this thing....a 40mph 12 thousand dollar bike, lighteweight and clean, would make more sense to everyone. I bet then even some sphere members would own one.

Loud. Weak. Slow. Over priced. Under-valued.
It's a suckers bike bro. Most ES folk would get suckered, even if the motor was twice the power.
 
liveforphysics said:
Loud. Weak. Slow. Over priced. Under-valued.
It's a suckers bike bro. Most ES folk would get suckered, even if the motor was twice the power.

Wow... :wink:

Normally i would say something like "for twice the power i will take two of them!"

But just like that i have been knocked off balance.

Is it just me who just loves this guy? He is like some electric bike bukowski or something...if he didnt make it in physics he could make it as some modern day poet.

Anyway that does it...i am putting this bike on craigslist tonight. Anyone else want data they better ask me for it or atleast ask me nicely here publically to keep the opti for a few more weeks. Is anyone curious about the batteries...they are supposedly american military specc...lipos...11.2 pounds 26amp hour, warranties for 30,000 miles or 3 years. Anyone want to look under the hood before i sell it? Physics?

I am gonna use the funds to buy another bike....from someone here on the sphere....and i am not giving details yet because i dont wanta get "swooped". i can only take so much and i really want to fit in with you guys and i agree if you guys ride with me on the opti your going to end up waiting for me a lot...and i can only take so much embarrasment here on the sphere. I dont want to be nicknamed 12k or something as we are riding.
 
extremegreenmachine said:
liveforphysics said:
Loud. Weak. Slow. Over priced. Under-valued.
It's a suckers bike bro. Most ES folk would get suckered, even if the motor was twice the power.

Wow... :wink:

Normally i would say something like "for twice the power i will take two of them!"

But just like that i have been knocked off balance.

Is it just me who just loves this guy? He is like some electric bike bukowski or something...if he didnt make it in physics he could make it as some modern day poet.

Anyway that does it...i am putting this bike on craigslist tonight. Anyone else want data they better ask me for it or atleast ask me nicely here publically to keep the opti for a few more weeks. Is anyone curious about the batteries...they are supposedly american military specc...lipos...11.2 pounds 26amp hour, warranties for 30,000 miles or 3 years. Anyone want to look under the hood before i sell it? Physics?

I am gonna use the funds to buy another bike....from someone here on the sphere....and i am not giving details yet because i dont wanta get "swooped". i can only take so much and i really want to fit in with you guys and i agree if you guys ride with me on the opti your going to end up waiting for me a lot...and i can only take so much embarrasment here on the sphere. I dont want to be nicknamed 12k or something as we are riding.

I would not get rid of something I spent 12 grand on just to gain the acceptance of some nerds on an internet forum :p
 
Fizz,

For the record i spend 7k on it, which was a steal. So i am not as stupid as i seem even to this crowd. They are a hard bunch and i do want there acceptance.

I have got a lot of great info from these guys.

They are engineer minded...and guys like me need guys like that. I was an english major and can only appreciate good prose when i see it.

You got to understand i am a poker player and have a lot of cash money right now and have no faith in the american economy or stock market based on what i am seeing in china...i am imagining china just sucking off the worlds oil supply as they take over the world economy with hobby-king type business models direct from china. I am doing everything i can in terms of spending on a 7k american product and raving about it, but despite my efforts we are about to become a nation of consumers and deliverers. The only new jobs are gonna be fedex and repair centers. I am putting my money into gold bricks and collector ebikes i can sale later after the armageddon hits. I am thinking "Mad Max" or "The Road" kind of scenarios and am thinking what type of bike i want to ride through the new mexico desert and be seen on in that kind of world....and i am thinking that bike needs to go 40mph and have 30 mile range for night prowling and for sneaking up quietly and stealing food, women and fuel and at the same time look like something mad max would ride...and the optibike isnt it. I think i want my next bike to have a Plattenberg Predator strapped on it....like a silent formula 1 on 2 or 3 wheels...1 2 3 and just see where i end up....and a big ass leather bag on the back....
 
extremegreenmachine said:
but even on lithium it is badly balanced, heavy, and handles like dog poop. I wouldnt trade any of my hub drives for it.

I seen a jackal in Berkeley once,
I like the look of it..

how is it 'badly balanced' ?

btw, I see that 'quadcarver' scooter in those photos you posted.
I met the inventor, he also is involved with the zuumer scooter..
 
Its got a hell of a lot weight to be riding on bicycle tires...

the suspension is made for bicycles and does not support that kind of weight.

I had a bad crash on one where i could not brake because it was too steep..hit a dip and it just went end over end...the suspension didnt seem to help. I hit the same stuff all the time on a suspension ebike and its a non event.

Really hurt myself. Worst e-vehicle crash ever for me...

Back then it was lead acid..maybe with lithium it would be better.

Hey i actually helped design the Jackal..in fact it was my idea to build it and i had the first 2 prototypes...i was even the one who named it "the Jackal". I wonder if bryan from TS motors still remembers.

It all started with a push scooter i had called the Scream...and it evolved into "the jackal"...
 
say chessmaster;

the anticipation & excitement over having a lunch meeting tomorrow with opti's marketing director is likely blinding u from even remotely considering that everything is not necessarily as rosy & cordial as it appears on the surface.

but...
given my well documented jaded outlook, it behooves me to point out;

do u not find it more than just a staggering coincidence that out of the blu, corney craig taber just happens to decide to drop in 4 a visit practically right on ur doorstep after only a couple of days since u began posting (from opti's view at least) 'negative' press about their product?

i don't believe in coincidence, something don't smell right.
i think he may hit u up with legal papers to cease & desist if not an out-right tort.
or he may offer u an authorized dealership to stem the tide.

idk, sumthins going on here, hope it's not a cap-n-da-a55 to shut u up. :lol:
hope i'm rong & probably am, just the same, watch yer bak.
 
Who are you calling corney chump?

I am in San Francisco every month, as my Burningman Camp throws the best parties in the city (in my humble opinion.)

I can tolerate you spouting off about my bikes, but I would appreciate it if you would keep the name calling to the kids in third grade.

Thanks!

Craig Taber
Optibike
 
CraigT said:
Who are you calling corney chump?

I am in San Francisco every month, as my Burningman Camp throws the best parties in the city (in my humble opinion.)

I can tolerate you spouting off about my bikes, but I would appreciate it if you would keep the name calling to the kids in third grade.

Thanks!

Craig Taber
Optibike








ooo, touchy.
so pleased to draw u out from the shadows.

ur in SF every month hunh?
show me where uve extended this kind of invite the previous dozen times over the past year.
its never happened b4.
do u really expect us to believe u that it's only just now @thistime it magically occured to u open it up to the public, that greenchessmachine's posts played no part in ur decision?


y do u even bother paying attention to our widdle spheroid when u harbour this kind of sentiment?
by all means, write ES off as being full of kooks with weird 'beliefs'.
except around here they're known as 'facts', like krushing optibike to the top of the hill.
it's the cult of opti suffering from unreal 'beliefs'.


Craig Taber nee Weakley said:
Godwin's Law:

Godwin's law (also known as Godwin's Rule of Nazi Analogies or
Godwin's Law of Nazi Analogies)[1][2] is a humorous observation made
by Mike Godwin in 1990[2] which has become an Internet adage. It
states: "As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a
comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1."[3][2] In other
words, Godwin put forth the hyperbolic observation that, given enough
time, in any online discussion—regardless of topic or scope— someone
inevitably criticizes some point made in the discussion by comparing
it to beliefs held by Hitler and the Nazis.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law

I propose Craig's Law:

Given enough time, in any online discussion about electric bikes-
regardless of topic or scope- someone inevitably criticizes some point
(or bike) in the discussion by referencing beliefs held by the small
group of home-built electric bike enthusiasts at Endless Sphere.

:)

Craig Taber




http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taber,_Alberta
 
Toorbough ULL-Zeveigh said:
so pleased to draw u out from the shadows.
Well played.
 
Ha! Yes, "beliefs" like your "belief" that I regard this board as a bunch of "kooks." I think this board is awesome, and I read it regularly, as I have said before.

I don't respond as much as some, hell, I don't even respond in the Optibike forum as much as I should- its just the way it is, I would suggest not reading into it.

I will say this, as I have said in the Optibike forum- Our belief is that a truly excellent electric bike excels in a multitude of arenas- Hill climbing, range, light weight, style, ease of use, blah blah blai h- the list goes on.

To build a bike that excels at SOME of these challenges, but not all, falls short of excellence in design, in my opinion. For example, hill climbing, like the "event" you mentioned: Congratulations, a 3000w electric bike beat an 850w Optibike up a hill. Not a big surprise there. How about a ride from Twin Peaks to the top of Mt. Tam and back as the second hill climb ride? I would love the see the results of that one- as the winner of that event will need to BALANCE hill climbing ability, range, efficiency and overall balance in order to complete the course in good form. In essence, a beautifully integrated design would prevail. Add into that equation a long battery warranty, top notch build quality and style points and you have a killer product.

But to compare a fully integrated, balanced electric bike built to do a number of things very well to a homebuilt E-chopper (not that I have anything against them!) in one short event is hardly an apples to apples comparison.

The Optibike is our version of electric bike excellence- we are continuing to learn, and we are continuing to innovate to build the worlds best electric bike.

Now seriously, do you really think I booked a trip to San Francisco because someone wrote something bad in this forum? Just say that sentence out loud to yourself to see how ridiculous it sounds.


Craig Taber
 
I have reserved my comments for the most part to see how things unraveled in this thread. I feel it is about time to share.


While we may not think a 12k optibike is a good value, there is a lot more to the equation than we are considering. Can we build a faster or more efficient bike for less? Sure. Can we build something as integrated and foolproof? Probably so. Can we do all of that and run a real company with employees and overhead costs? Highly doubtful. The idea of a $12k ebike isn't just about the bike. It is about having a company that will be there for support and future revisions. When you poo poo the idea of the optibike, you are also poo pooing the idea of a domestic company offering a highly engineered bike with full customer service and warranty. Don't be mad if Optibike goes away and all we have left is Ezee type bikes, because that is what we will get if we don't have companies like Opti around to think outside the chinese bike.


While this bike may not be the choice for me or the majority of the forum, I am highly disappointed that the brilliant minds on the forum can't see past their own experience to understand the value of a bike isn't always measured in numbers. Not everybody wants to fuss with electronics. Not everybody wants to convert a bike. Not everybody is comfortable with voiding warranties or buying a bike without a warranty. The world looks flat from where you stand, but on the other side of that hill is somebody that is just as right about ebikes as you while being 180 degrees in opinion.


If this forum is right that the Optibike is so overpriced, we will see new entrants to the market in the next few years that will start to play price wars. In the mean time, tearing down the few companies that are in the market will only scare away potential startups!!
 
Any position purporting criticism of the top-crow having a "chilling effect" is specious bordering on absurd. Particularly when it comes from "the small group of home-built electric bike enthusiasts at Endless Sphere".
 
Is this not "a small group of home built electric bike enthusiasts?" No insult intended. I've got nothin but love for ya.
 
I want to complain about the Tesla Roadster now too. How dare they charge so much when I could put one together myself for cheaper! If it were half the price I might consider it :p

If only the volumes could double or quadruple. Then we would start to get a market going that could support lower prices.


We are still in the innovator and enthusiast times of electric bikes in the US. Hopefully we can watch it blossom into early adopters and majority users and bring hundreds of thousands of ebikes onto our road system instead of just tens of thousands per year. 50cc bikes for daily travels under 15 miles are the low hanging fruit of product substitution with this sort of equipment. I just see the market as converging on this point from two directions. One is the ebike side, either cheap and heavy or light and expensive. The second is the e-scooter side with 100lb 30mph machines. We have obviously found the first mover for the light and $$$ ebike front- Optibike.
 
Funny you mention tesla...one of their highest volume locations is in the same town as our new 7500 sq ft flagship store (opening july 1)....Boulder, CO. The shift is happening.
 
CraigT said:
Now seriously, do you really think I booked a trip to San Francisco because someone wrote something bad in this forum? Just say that sentence out loud to yourself to see how ridiculous it sounds.

what's not ridiculous & why i find ur motives suspect is that uve attempted this b4 on the mod from the tidalforce forum.
the tried & tru marketing tactic of cutting off the head of the snake so the body will die.
trying to buy him off in the hopes of turning a critic into a cheerleader.

deerfencer said:
A year or so ago Craig and Jim from Opti tried to get me to trade in my beloved modified Tidalforce S750X (Uma) by offering me a killer deal on an Opti with a generous trade-in allowance for Uma but I was simply not interested in swapping silent power for a less powerful buzz bomb.

ive no doubt u do indeed make regular trips to SF.
the only salient point uve deliberately chosen to ignore in order to shift the focus away from it i'll repeat here:
Toorbough ULL-Zeveigh said:
show me where uve extended this kind of invite the previous dozen times over the past year.
its never happened b4.

i.e. not the trip itself but why make the visit public at this particular time.
clearly there has to be an impetus for this sudden & drastic change in routine.
that u expect us to believe this should happen like lightning out of the blu, that's what sounds ridiculous.
the conversation in boulder could have gone something along the lines of;

"ya know, i'm headed to SF anyways. i should have breakfast with guy. do a sell job on him, feel him out on how best to get him to change his tune. i'll just post an open invite on the opti-forum that i don't frequent. i guarantee he'll snap up the bait like an ol' big-mouth bass".

am i close? no matter, if nothing else it's an opportunity 4u to write off the trip as a business expense, no doubt ule be keeping the receipts for the breakfast.

btw, do they have name for this common tactic in marketing school, shifting focus in order to steer the conversation away from areas u don't want to answer?
i notice goldberg does that a lot, actually so do most republicans so i would appreciate if anyone can come up with a suitable label.
the sasquehanee shuffle?






CraigT said:
But to compare a fully integrated, balanced electric bike built to do a number of things very well to a homebuilt E-chopper (not that I have anything against them!) in one short event is hardly an apples to apples comparison.

exactly spot-on the nose correct, on any given sunday it's for anyone to take the prize.
and yet strangely when it's the reverse case u don't seem to concede or excuse the same disparity when its opti that comes out on top like @PP.

first off, it's never a level playing field (p.i.) when any privateer has to go up against a factory team with a much bigger budget & support crew but additionally the damn mountain is in right in ur own back yard!
that's a huge disadvantage with travel & lodging expense heaped onto the privateers but there's no apples to apples complaining from u on this score.
no, u do a turkey trot all year long over ur vainglorious conquering of PP, squeezing mileage out of the win fer all she's worth.
optibikes PP wins aren't the result of being so much better but rather that it's had a very easy time of it.
actually optibike has never faced a truly serious challenger simply due to in large part of the expense in just getting there.
as someone recently posted in the deathrace thread, 90% of winning is simply showing up.

i wuvs the comment from a long time opti owner & recent stealth buyer when he finds out exactly how steep is the big bad scary PP that he's heard so much hype about (largely from CraigT); "15%... that's it?!!"
have u noticed how the single largest segment of stealth bomber customers consists of opti owners?
calling the stock crystalyte X5 a 'superhub', considering what they've become accustomed to i can c y.






CraigT said:
How about a ride from Twin Peaks to the top of Mt. Tam and back as the second hill climb ride? I would love the see the results of that one- as the winner of that event will need to BALANCE hill climbing ability, range, efficiency and overall balance in order to complete the course in good form.

sur, but only if optibike will do it with the cranks off so u can't pedal, same as the 9cBMX without a chain.
ya c, this is where opti is bit of a con-job.
they gets the user to pay big bucks, have him do a big chunk of the heavy lifting, then take all the credit for how efficient & advanced it is, why it's worth all that money. :roll:
without the cranks then we can c what the bike is really made of.





CraigT said:
Ha! Yes, "beliefs" like your "belief" that I regard this board as a bunch of "kooks." I think this board is awesome, and I read it regularly, as I have said before.

actually what uve said is u think ES is full of Nazi's.


Craig said:
someoneinevitably criticizes some point made in the discussion by comparing
it to beliefs held by Hitler and the Nazis.

Craig said:
someone inevitably criticizes some point
(or bike) in the discussion by referencing beliefs held by the small
group of home-built electric bike enthusiasts at Endless Sphere.

u make a straight-up substitution for 'Hilter' with 'group of home-built electric bike enthusiasts'.
u make a straight-up substitution for 'Nazis' with 'Endless Sphere'.
with the express intent of subtly leaving an impression in the readers mind linking the two together all the while making out like u didn't cut one.

so what do they call this tactic in marketing school?

here's some good advice.
u shud follow it.

CraigT said:
I would appreciate it if you would keep the name calling to the kids in third grade.
 
Back
Top