I had to dig to find this old original Photon thread. Whilst I consider upgrading to the Gen 2 or maybe even the new Pro I keep riding my Gen 1 Photon.
Last week we did the 4-day Bon Ton Roulet tour up in the finger lakes region of NY. Absolutely beautiful back roads with some nice lakefront views, albeit on busier roads. I rode my Canondale F1000 hardtail with Photon, my buddy and his wife also on Photon bikes, and his brother on a factory Trek FX something e-bike. My bike performed flawlessly and I did 185 miles in 4 days, longest day was 63 miles. I probably could have done the optional century that day except I rode part of the way with my slow friends who are too social with their riding... lots of starts and stops, yakking and conferring, and just slow in general. That's OK for awhile but not if you want to do serious miles. I prefer to get into a good rhythm and flow and bang out the miles.
Her Photon bike had some issues where it would randomly turn off, as in no power at all, even to the display. I suspect some issue with the BMS or motor controller tripping but not sure how he will go about trying to diagnose that.
As far as the Trek bike with a low power Bosch motor, the Photon seems to be better in almost every way, except maybe a little noisier. My friend's brother is new to doing longer rides and ridiculous upright geometry of the Trek was not really suitable to that. I tried to coach him on some possible changes to improve his riding position but the geometry of the bike will be somewhat limiting.